Peter Crouch
Stoke striker on BBC One

"It's not a penalty. Nathan Dyer turns into the ball and I think the referee has given it because there was a bit of distance the ball travelled.

"But Dyer has stuck his hand out to block the run of Danny Rose and it's just hit the ball."

Martin O'Neill
Republic of Ireland manager on BBC One

"I agree with Alan, it's a very harsh penalty - Nathan Dyer has just turned round and doesn't know where the ball is. Doesn't it have to be deliberate?"

Thomas Huysinga: Subjectivity is the nature of football. How is technology supposed to benefit 50/50 decisions?

Michael Davis: Ridiculous decision for penalty. Never ever intentional. Crazy ref or crazy rules?

Jonny Magrinho: Why is that not a penalty? He's stuck his arm out & hit his hand on to the ball to take it away from the attacker. Clear penalty!

Can I tempt you with our final course of the evening? Cardiff v Shrewsbury...

We'll be bringing you plenty of analysis from the Lane in the meantime.

Alan Shearer
Former England striker on BBC One

"I think that's a very poor decision - it's not a penalty at all, Nathan Dyer doesn't even know where the ball is. It's very harsh."

It's just been pointed out to me that Tottenham v Leicester II is on Wednesday in the Premier League. These two will be sick of each other by the end of the month.

Familiarity breeds contempt and all that.

David Pleat
Former Tottenham boss on BBC Radio 5 live

"It's been an outstanding, exciting cup tie. Nobody has been short-changed tonight. When the teams were announced we thought they were being disrespectful to the competition but that has not been the case at all. A superb game with both sides deserving to stay in the hat.

"The referee is the only one who knows whether it was a penalty."

Forget Fury v Klitschko II. It's all about Tottenham v Leicester II.

OK... I'm getting carried away. But if the replay is as good as this first game, we're in for a treat.

That's your lot.

Tempers have become a little frayed as both teams look to land the knockout blow in this ferocious contest. Sixty seconds to find a hero.

Jonathan Pearce
BBC football commentator on BBC One

"Looking at the replays I think that's a very harsh penalty against Leicester."

Kevin Kilbane: "It is harsh but it was hand to ball - Nathan Dyer has flicked his hand out at the ball going past him."

Mit: Ouch. Don't think it was a penalty at all. Decent composure from Kane to level the game. Harsh on Leicester

MP: Dyer decision from the ref

Thebugler69: Could anyone tell me how that's deliberate handball? Awful awful decision.

Three minutes of time added on. Tottenham, as you would expect, pouring forward.

David Pleat
Former Tottenham boss on BBC Radio 5 live

"I don't think either manager wants a replay but it's no more than Tottenham deserve."

Kevin Kilbane
Former Everton winger on BBC One

"Bobby Madley taken up good positions got the key decisions right today.

"I think Nathan Dyer recognised the ball was beyond him and he had a little flick at it. It's the correct decision.

"Harry Kane was under pressure but he was cool, composed, he went for power and scored with a really good penalty."

Image source, Reuters

Penalty! Drama!

Danny Rose tries to nip past Nathan Dyer and the ball hits the Leicester man on the hand. Soft... but he did handle it away from Rose.

Image source, Reuters

Tottenham have raised it now. If they were playing Football Manager 2005, they'd be in 'ultra attacking mode'. This time a cross comes in which Dele Alli heads wide. All hands to deck now.

Kevin Kilbane
Former Everton winger on BBC One

"Better goalkeeping from Kasper Schmeichel that time, palming it well away from any danger."