Summary

  • Another Christiansen penalty seals the win

  • Beattie's stoppage time header puts City ahead

  • Birmingham have captain Harrop sent off

  • Christiansen penalty levels for Man City

  • Quinn puts Birmingham ahead from range

  1. Postpublished at 57 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Marc SkinnerImage source, Rex Features

    His side may be ahead and looking comfortable for now, but Birmingham boss Marc Skinner is still barking orders from the sidelines.

    Whatever he's said tactically speaking, it's certainly paid off up to this point - Man City really haven't been allowed to get into their stride.

    The hosts have made their first change, with Claire Emslie replacing fellow Scot Jane Ross.

  2. Postpublished at 54 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Has Man City goalie Ellie Roebuck learned her lesson?

    It would seem not, as she once again takes a bad touch in her box and almost gets closed down by a Birmingham forward.

    Lightning almost struck twice.

  3. Postpublished at 50 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Man CityImage source, Rex Features

    The hosts already look brighter since the restart, with more purpose and pace to their play.

    From Man City's perspective, they probably think they can't possibly play as averagely as they did in that first half.

  4. Second halfpublished at 46 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    With Nick Cushing's words still no doubt ringing in their ears, Man City get this second half started.

    Can the hosts possibly maintain their 100% WSL 1 record?

  5. Postpublished at 13:34 Greenwich Mean Time 29 October 2017

    HT: Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    The teams are slowly reemerging at the Academy Stadium in Manchester, and we'll be back under way shortly.

    Should be expect changes from the hosts?

  6. Get WSL goal alerts to your phonepublished at 13:30 Greenwich Mean Time 29 October 2017

    HT: Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Chelsea LadiesImage source, Empics

    I know we're well into the WSL 1 season now, but you may not be aware that it's now possible to get notifications for line-ups, goals, kick-off, half-time and results sent to your mobile via the BBC Sport app.

    Want to know more? Visit this page to find out how to sign-up.

  7. get involved

    Get Involved via #bbcfootballpublished at 13:26 Greenwich Mean Time 29 October 2017

    HT: Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    ArsenalImage source, Getty Images

    As always, you can get in touch with us on all things WSL 1 via Twitter.

    Whether it's about the departure of Arsenal manager Pedro Martinez Losa, the retirement of former England defender Alex Scott or on what you've just seen in that first half.

    Use #bbcfootball and we'll pick up your comments.

  8. Postpublished at 13:22 Greenwich Mean Time 29 October 2017

    HT: Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Here's a reminder of the decisive moment of the first half.

    Man City try to play out from the back but keeper Ellie Roebuck wants too much time and is closed down.

    Skipper Steph Houghton could still have done better though, and Lucy Quinn's strike is right on the money.

  9. HALF-TIMEpublished at 13:20 Greenwich Mean Time 29 October 2017

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Lucy Quinn's floated effort separates the sides at the midway point.

    Man City aren't used to being behind and Birmingham aren't used to leading against the league's big favourites.

    Plenty to look forward to in the second half.

  10. Postpublished at 45+1 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Two minutes added on at the end of the first half.

    There are faint shouts from the stands for a Man City penalty following Hayley Ladd's challenge in the box - but they are rightly ignored.

  11. Houghton's set-piece threatpublished at 43 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Jo Potter
    England and Reading midfielder on BBC Red Button

    I've been with her on England camps and Steph Houghton spends time to perfect her free-kicks.

    She'll be disappointed with herself there, but she'll be looking to get more and find her range.

  12. GREAT SAVE!published at 41 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    The technique from Kiera Walsh, the save from Ann-Katrin Berger - wow!

    The ball comes out from a Man City corner and Walsh lashes it first time on the half volley from all of 25 yards.

    It seems destined for the top corner but German stopper Berger wonderfully gets across to tip it wide.

  13. CLOSE!published at 38 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    That was speculative, but it so nearly came off for Birmingham's Jess Carter.

    The 20-year-old flicks on a long-throw and it comes back to her - and her strike is not too far over and wide of the Man City goal.

  14. Postpublished at 35 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    I perhaps owe Man City's Scottish striker Jane Ross an apology for the gloves reference (see 12:46 GMT post).

    England and Reading midfielder Jo Potter, speaking on the BBC Red Button coverage, says Ross has a circulation problem - which would explain the need for added warmth.

    As you might be able to tell, there's not a whole lot happening on the pitch - Birmingham are being allowed to have the ball, and are doing things at their own pace.

  15. Postpublished at 31 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Chelsea Ladies' fans will be rubbing their hands together here - they're the only other side in WSL 1 yet to drop any points.

    Man City had won all three of their league games coming into this one, but haven't created too many openings thus far.

    Melissa Lawley has looked a threat, but the hosts haven't got her on the ball enough.

  16. Will Man City switch tactics?published at 27 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Jo Potter
    England and Reading midfielder on BBC Red Button

    It'll be interesting to see if Man City change the way they play at half time.

    Will they adopt a higher press, to try and stop Birmingham at source?

  17. Postpublished at 25 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Man City are winning a number of set pieces now, and that's when the likes of Jill Scott come into their element.

    Birmingham are content to play on the counter, and why shouldn't they be?

  18. Postpublished at 21 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    Nick CushingImage source, Rex Features

    Man City manager Nick Cushing was all smiles before kick-off, but I doubt he's quite as chirpy right now.

    His side are starting to stamp their authority on the match, but Birmingham look organised and now have something to hold onto.

    Former Birmingham player Izzy Christiansen plays a role in a clever Man City corner routine, but it comes to nothing.

  19. WATCH: Quinn puts Birmingham aheadpublished at 19 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    The hosts started brightly, but Birmingham grew slowly into the game and this "terrific strike" from Lucy Quinn has given Marc Skinner's side the lead.

    I'm not sure Ellie Roebuck or Steph Houghton will be particularly happy with their role in the opening goal...

  20. CLOSE!published at 14 mins

    Man City 0-1 Birmingham

    The home side have come to terms with falling behind and create their first meaningful chance.

    It's a clipped ball into the box and Jane Ross meets it with her head, but it powers just over.

    Man City forward Ross is wearing gloves by the way - I know it's late October, but still?!