One minute added on as Marcus Rashford is offside from Paul Pogba's pass.

Reindeer Hotdog: If United lose this I guarantee we will see a plethora of tweets saying "Ole out!" and yet if they win it'll be 'in spite' of his tactics. The guy is a United legend and has done more for the club than any other manager since Ferguson. Where is the respect?

Dion Dublin
Former Man Utd and Aston Villa striker on BBC Radio 5 Live

I'm actually shattered watching this game, because it is now being played at a furious pace.

It is like a basketball game, but the football itself isn't great because both sides are giving the ball away.

Scott McTominay has had more touches in the opposition's box than any other player so far (eight).

Dawesy: Has anyone ever seen any benefit of playing out from the back? It’s always looks like causing issues for your own team

Richard: The only reason Ole is leaving Rashford on is to take a penalty. You can't play for penalties for the last 30 minutes of the game. Make the change and WIN THE GAME. Then you don't need to worry about penalties.

United counter quickly from the corner but a bounce doesn't favour Marcus Rashford and Etienne Capoue beats him in the air.

It's not a bad inswinger from Dani Parejo and David de Gea claws it over the bar for a corner.

Image source, Getty Images

Villarreal have a free-kick now on the left wing. They're sending men forward.

Obviously those messages were sent just before Fred came on.

Steven: What sort of message does this send to the guys on the bench?! basically hes saying he doesn't trust any of them to come on and change the game, even though rashford has been shocking to name but one.

Gscatha: Solskjaer yet again showing his management naivety. It's time to make a substitution!

Neil Lennon
Former Celtic manager on BBC Radio 5 Live

What is this saying about Manchester United's squad? This is a worry for me.

United make a sub! Fred replaces Mason Greenwood. Interesting. Conservative?

Paco Alcacer shoots over now inside the box.

Image source, Getty Images

Dion Dublin
Former Man Utd and Aston Villa striker on BBC Radio 5 Live

Juan Mata does have a few keys, like he could unlock a door for Edinson Cavani or Marcus Rashford but after him I do start to struggle with Manchester United's bench to be honest with you.

It's not attack v defence by any means now. I'd say it's been fairly even in extra time.

What a waste. Villarreal work the ball well to Alberto Moreno on the corner of the box. He should really blast it across goal - there are players in there - but aims for the near top corner and it's high and wide.

Neil Lennon
Former Celtic manager on BBC Radio 5 Live

Manchester United just look a bit leggy.

Gerard Moreno drifts in behind United's defence from a cross but heads into the side-netting.