Manchester

Welcome to Proper Manc

A bomb, gang turf wars and the rise of club culture - poet, author and broadcaster David Scott looks at Manchester in the 1990s

Watch & Listen

Latest Updates

  1. Bournemouth 2-1 Man City - the fans' verdictpublished at 11:27

    Your views banner
    Pep Guardiola, manager of Manchester City sits on the bench during the Premier League match between AFC Bournemouth and Manchester City FC at Vitality StadiumImage source, Getty Images

    We asked for your thoughts after Saturday's Premier League game between Bournemouth and Manchester City.

    Here are some of your comments:

    Bournemouth fans:

    Rob: A monkey off our back with the City win! Can you really now say, "it was an off day for City" and also, "an off day" in the Arsenal game? And... were Villa also having an "off day"? I think Bournemouth deserve more credit. Up the Cherries.

    Steve: A tremendous performance from the Cherries. Iraola’s tactics were played out to perfection and rather than go for the low block many teams use against City, Cherries played their natural attacking game and took it to the champions from the first minute. Still buzzing 24 hours later. Europa Conference spot could be in reach.

    Derek: Another great performance, seven points from three top teams. As seems to be often the case the result is portrayed as being due to top team being off par rather than Bournemouth playing well and taking the game to the opposition. Iraola has instilled a belief and collective teamwork that does not give up and works from start to finish. Joy to watch.

    Peter: A historic win. I think we knew as fans that we can beat anyone at home. We have to keep hold of Semenyo and Kerkez. Evanilson is fitting in well. I hope the last three games give the team the belief that they can challenge in the top half of the table. Iraola is a magician!

    Man City fans:

    Suraj: Very disappointing, don’t understand why the performance was so flat. I know we’ve got injuries, but we still had a strong side. Not sure why more were not used, maybe Pep’s worried about more injuries. Liverpool I think are the ones to look out for as unlike us they came back from behind. I'm just not feeling confident for this season.

    Abdullah: City were off it today. Until Jeremy Doku came on we were actually horrendous and were shown how to play. Doku and Gvardiol our only positive players. Semenyo and Kerkez were outstanding and fair play to Evanilson, who converted his sole chance (something we couldn't do). You can't control injuries but we will bounce back soon, we always do.

    Steve: A lacklustre performance from us, proven by the fact it was the 80th minute for our first shot on goal to arrive. After four consecutive titles, I am not convinced we have the same hunger we had in previous seasons. One positive out of the game was another excellent performance by Nunes. Congrats to Bournemouth, who thoroughly deserved the win.

    Roger: City have been fragile defensively all season and combined with an aging midfield and several players all striving to find their best form this defeat was long overdue. Pep will no doubt turn it round but possibly might need to use some fringe players to achieve it.

    An image detailing how to follow your Premier League team on BBC Sport: "On the app? Tap the bell icon to get news about your club sent to you. Signed in on a browser? Hit 'Follow' to stay up to date.
  2. Man Utd 1-1 Chelsea - the fans' verdictpublished at 11:17

    Your views banner
    Rasmus Hojlund of Manchester United and Chelsea's Wesley Fofana battle for possessionImage source, Getty Images

    We asked for your thoughts after Sunday's Premier League game between Manchester United and Chelsea.

    Here are some of your comments:

    Man Utd fans:

    Ray: Poor team performance. Thought there would be a bounce from the players with Ten Hag gone but more of the same - no cohesion between defence, midfield and forwards.

    Andrew: I pity our new manager - we are a complete shambles. Clueless. Playing for fouls and appealing to the ref is all we are good at. Worst I have ever witnessed in 58 years.

    Adam: It was a solid performance, but the lack of goals is becoming a concern now. United are six points off the top four but, in reality, we are nowhere near the teams above us in terms of an identity and style of play.

    Christine: It was a little better but still a team with no identity as such. It is going to take Amorim some time to sort out this mess. The defence is too leaky and the press is not fast enough. These players are not good enough and it's going to take time to change this team.

    Chelsea fans:

    John: It's a pity that we sent Petrovic out on loan. He is a good goalkeeper, and unfortunately Sanchez is going to prove very costly for us this season. Hopefully we can accumulate enough points to get top four without a quality keeper. Caicedo is immense for us at the minute - he's quality.

    Alan: Largely dull and boring. If the manager is happy with this performance then I would be surprised. We just do not know how to get the ball in the net. When pushed, our defence falls to bits. From previous games, we seemed to go backwards with our progress. At times, it was hard to believe we are in the top six playing against a team in the lower half.

    Nick: A decent performance without being exciting. We didn't seem to offer much of a threat in the final third. Satisfied with a point after going a goal down. Feeling positive about the remainder of the season. I think fourth place is achievable.

    Stu: I thought we were off it. Considering these players haven't played in a week they just didn't convince. Sanchez is the worst goalkeeper we've ever had. He's costing us goals almost every game and yet Maresca won't replace him. Says it all really.

    An image detailing how to follow your Premier League team on BBC Sport: "On the app? Tap the bell icon to get news about your club sent to you. Signed in on a browser? Hit 'Follow' to stay up to date.
  3. Fernandes 'a player you build the team around'published at 09:56

    Bruno Fernandes celebrates a goal for Manchester UnitedImage source, Getty Images

    On Sunday's episode of Match of the Day 2, former England internationals Phil Jones and Danny Murphy looked at captain Bruno Fernandes' importance to Manchester United and where he fits in when new head coach Ruben Amorim takes charge later this month.

    Fernandes' former United team-mate Jones said: "I get the impression he's almost misinterpreted at times, I can only go from my own experience in the dressing room that I spent with him.

    "He's a leader in the dressing room and he's brilliant with the younger lads. We've all got different captains and he's a leader who leads by example, in terms of the qualities he brings. He's a player that you build the team around.

    "He wants to win. Being at Manchester United is a heavy shirt to wear and I feel with him being the captain, he can certainly wear that shirt."

    Assessing his performance in Sunday's 1-1 draw against Chelsea, Murphy said: "No United player has really been outstanding this season, that's fair enough to say, and Bruno included - he's admitted it himself more or less.

    "But when they need somebody to be brave and creative, he stands up to be counted and again he did [against Chelsea].

    "Nearly all of the moments when United open up teams, he's involved somewhere. It doesn't matter what the score is, how big the crowd is, whether they're moaning or happy, he's always trying little things.

    "When the new man comes in, irrelevant of system or how he wants to play, he'll have to find a place for Fernandes because he is United's best creative spark."

    Watch Match of the Day 2

    Watch on BBC iPlayer banner
  4. Man Utd players 'showing different appetite'published at 08:06

    Ruud van Nistelrooy points from the touchlineImage source, PA Media

    Former Manchester United manager David Moyes and ex-Premier League midfielder Nigel Reo-Coker have spoken to the BBC's Football Daily podcast about United's two performances under interim boss Ruud van Nistelrooy since the exit of Erik ten Hag.

    Reo-Coker: "Even though it's only been two games, I see a vast improvement from what we saw from the players' performances under Ten Hag. They are running more, they're showing a greater desire to win.

    "Even just the body language, the way Ruud embraces the players after the game and the players with him, that tells you a bigger, deeper story than just a feelgood factor right now."

    Moyes: "I come from another side of it - I think it would be wrong of the players if they just suddenly put in a couple of good performances for the new manager. It would tell you more about the players than the manager they've just lost.

    "United have had some of the best managers in the world recently, like Van Gaal and Mourinho, Ten Hag had a great record as well. I think United were very loyal to Erik and gave him every opportunity to get it right. But I'd hate the thought that the players are suddenly starting to perform better because somebody else has taken over.

    "At United, the scrutiny is incredible and the manager takes the brunt of it, which they do at all football clubs, but at a club like United the players are an important part of it. I hope that the players have just stepped it up in the past week or two but it was nothing to do with the manager."

    Reo-Coker: "Ruud hasn't really changed anything tremendously, which is why you'd say it probably is on the players. He's still started in the same formation Ten Hag was playing, but it's just a different appetite that the players are showing.

    "It's unfortunate because United were very loyal to Ten Hag, but since the change has happened, you can see a different kind of energy in the players. Nothing has changed much in terms of formation and tactics."

    Listen to more analysis on BBC Sounds

  5. Gossip: Gyokeres has no exit planpublished at 07:58

    Gossip graphic

    Sweden striker Viktor Gyokeres does not plan to follow Sporting manager Ruben Amorim in leaving the Lisbon club to join Manchester United. Amorim will become the new manager at Old Trafford on 11 November. (Record - in Portuguese), external

    Manchester United and Chelsea have joined Tottenham in the race to sign 20-year-old Denmark left-back Patrick Dorgu from Lecce. (Football Insider), external

    Want more transfer news? Read Monday's full gossip column

  6. 'I haven't spoken to Amorim'published at 20:44 3 November

    Manchester United interim manager Ruud van Nistelrooy applauds the support after the Premier League match between Manchester United FC and Chelsea FC at Old TraffordImage source, Getty Images

    Ruud van Nistelrooy on his future with new manager Ruben Amorim: "Over the coming days we will be in communication and I am waiting for that. What is more important is that we are in training tomorrow and prepare for the game on Thursday. I haven’t spoken to him [Amorim] yet but it will happen.

    “You saw today that we competed well against a very good side. This is the way forward for this group of players."