Summary

  • Breast surgeon Ian Paterson guilty of wounding

  • He performed needless operations on patients

  • There were ten victims - nine women and a man

  • Paterson 'wanted to play God'

  • He mutilated women 'for power'

  • Updates from Friday 28 April 2017

  1. Breast surgeon 'stuck knife in for no reason'published at 08:32 British Summer Time 29 April 2017

    Jade Edgington was 16 when disgraced surgeon Ian Paterson first operated on her unnecessarily.

    Read More
  2. Stressed out? Step into the 'rage room'published at 18:55 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Workers are being offered a smashing way to relieve stress - with old office equipment and a baseball bat.

    Read More
  3. 'God complex' breast surgeon guiltypublished at 18:11 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Ian Paterson conducted "extensive, life-changing operations for no medically-justifiable reason".

    Read More
  4. Surgeon 'psychopathic like Shipman'published at 18:02 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    What drove a trusted breast surgeon to carry out botched and dangerous operations on hundreds of patients?

    Read More
  5. Our coverage of breast surgeon court case across the daypublished at 18:00 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    The Live team has been bringing you updates about disgraced 'God complex' breast surgeon Ian Paterson throughout Friday afternoon.

    While that's all from us on Friday, we'll be back from 08:00 on Tuesday with our usual mix of news, sport, travel and weather.

    In the meantime, keep an eye out here for more on Paterson - and other breaking news.

  6. Recap: Breast surgeon whose needless procedures wounded patientspublished at 17:58 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Here's a recap of the main points in the case of breast surgeon Ian Paterson who has been convicted this afternoon of wounding patients in a series of needless procedures. 

    - Ian Paterson, 59, of Greater Manchester, has been found guilty of 17 counts of wounding with intent 

    - He has also been convicted of three counts of unlawful wounding 

    - They relate to nine women and one man 

    - A seven-week trial heard their accounts - representing a sample of those Paterson treated - of operations carried out between 1997 and 2011 at the private Little Aston and Parkway hospitals in the West Midlands 

    - Jurors have decided the surgeon carried out "extensive, life-changing operations for no medically-justifiable reason"

    - He has been granted bail and is due to be sentenced in May

  7. Breast surgeon 'grossly exaggerated' symptomspublished at 17:56 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A victim of Ian Paterson opted for a mastectomy and immediate reconstruction after the surgeon told her he had found a "ticking bomb" of cancerous cells.

    Patricia Welch

    But when Patricia Welch's case was reviewed, an expert found her symptoms had been grossly exaggerated. 

    She says Paterson "won't suffer" as all of his victims have suffered for many years.

    Quote Message

    Hate is a strong word. I've never hated anyone in my life before, but it's pretty close."

    Patricia Welch, Paterson patient

  8. Repeat of Paterson's actions 'unlikely'published at 17:45 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A charitable organisation dedicated to advancing standards of breast surgery says a case like that of Ian Paterson is "unlikely" to happen again.

    Ian PatersonImage source, Trinity Mirror

    The 59-year-old surgeon has been convicted of seventeen counts of wounding with intent in relation to a series of unnecessary operations. 

    He was released on bail and is due to be sentenced next month at Nottingham Crown Court. 

    Quote Message

    These cases took place before 2011 and a lot of things have changed in medical vigilance since then...There is much greater monitoring of the cases that are carried out by surgeons in private health care."

    Mark Sibbering, Incoming president of the Association of Breast Surgery

  9. Breast surgeon's NHS work was under scrutinypublished at 17:31 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A breast surgeon has today been found guilty of wounding patients in a series of unnecessary procedures at private hospitals.

    But it wasn't just Ian Paterson's private work that was a cause for concern. He was also employed by the NHS at the Heart of England Trust, based in and around Birmingham and while his job here did not form part of the criminal case, there are serious questions about his work. 

    An independent report in 2013, external, by lawyer Sir Ian Kennedy, found concerns about Paterson dated back to 2003 but were not dealt with for four years.

    He said bosses at the Heart of England NHS Trust were told of concerns but "brushed them under the carpet".

  10. Healthcare group 'sorry' for 'distress' caused by breast surgeonpublished at 17:23 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Breast surgeon Ian Paterson's seven-week trial heard from 10 victims - representing a sample of those Paterson treated - who were operated on between 1997 and 2011 at the privately-run Little Aston and Parkway hospitals in the West Midlands.

    The sites are run by Spire Healthcare.

    A statement said: "We would like to reiterate how truly sorry we are for the distress experienced by any patients affected by this case.

    "We can say unequivocally that we have learned the lessons from these events. We commissioned a thorough independent investigation and have fully implemented all of the recommendations."

  11. Relative of breast surgeon's victim 'fighting in her memory'published at 17:09 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    The relative of a victim of Ian Paterson says the surgeon had a "God complex".

    Shirley Moroney and Marie PinfieldImage source, MORONEY FAMILY
    Image caption,

    Marie Pinfield (left) and her sister Shirley Moroney were best friends

    Shirley Moroney's sister, Marie Pinfield, asked Paterson for a double mastectomy in 2006 when she was diagnosed with advanced breast cancer. 

    But instead of waking up with the flat chest she expected, the surgeon had used the controversial "cleavage-sparing" surgical technique which had left so much tissue behind she had to wear a bra. 

    Marie asked for corrective surgery but the delay to chemotherapy and radiotherapy meant she developed secondary cancer in her lung and died in October 2008. 

    Quote Message

    Marie believed in justice, and right and wrong,...I know she will be looking down on me, willing me to go on."

    Shirley Moroney, Sister of Paterson victim Marie Pinfield

  12. Breast surgeon with 'lack of respect' for women mutilated them 'for power'published at 16:45 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A patient of Ian Paterson says he twice operated on her and told her she appeared to be developing cancer.

    Cheryl Iommi later learned the lumps the breast surgeon claimed were a cancer risk were simply scar tissue left behind from his botched procedures.   

    Cheryl IommiImage source, Gavin Dickson

    She says she feels like she's been "duped" and "seriously misled".

    Quote Message

    I think he did it for power - and a lack of respect for women. Why mutilate women so they no longer want their partners to look at them?"

    Cheryl Iommi, Paterson patient

  13. Breast surgeon was 'repeatedly asked to stop'published at 16:33 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Here's some analysis from health correspondent Dominic Hughes on 'God complex' breast surgeon Ian Paterson:

    "It wasn't just Ian Paterson's private work that was a cause for concern.

    "He was also employed by the NHS at the Heart of England Trust, based in and around Birmingham.

    "His job here did not form part of the criminal case but there are serious questions about his work.

    "In 2011 it emerged he had been performing an unorthodox and unregulated procedure known as a cleavage-sparing mastectomy."

    Media caption,

    What is cleavage-sparing surgery?

    Dominic continues:

    "By definition, a mastectomy removes the whole breast, but this procedure left some tissue behind, putting women at risk of the cancer returning.

    "Despite repeatedly being asked to stop by managers, Ian Paterson continued to use the technique for several years."

  14. Paterson case 'complex'published at 16:23 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Police say the investigation into the breast surgeon who wounded patients with unnecessary operations at West Midlands hospitals took a long time due to its complexity.

    Ian Paterson

    The crimes of Ian Paterson, 59, related to nine women and one man. 

    DS Dale Robertson of West Midlands Police says records stretching back nearly 20 years ago were required to put the case together accurately. 

  15. 'He stuck knife in me unnecessarily' - victimpublished at 16:09 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A victim of 'God complex' breast surgeon Ian Paterson says she felt 'violated' by the unnecessary surgery to which she was subjected. 

    Jade EdgingtonImage source, RICHARD T HARRIS

    Jade Edgington was 16 and studying for A-levels when she found a lump in her breast while in the shower. 

    She was then introduced to Paterson and by the time she was 19 had undergone four invasive operations, later learning three of them were unnecessary.  

    Quote Message

    Why put us all through that? You feel almost violated - essentially, someone has stuck a knife in me unnecessarily. You can't believe a man of his calibre has put somebody through something like that..."

    Jade Edgington, Paterson patient

  16. 'I feel betrayed'published at 16:02 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    More now from Debbie Douglas, a former patient of breast surgeon Ian Paterson who has this afternoon been speaking of her ordeal.

    She attended court, but did not give evidence, and said after Paterson's conviction for multiple counts of wounding: "I thought I had the best of consultants. All these years down the line, I feel I've been betrayed."

    Media caption,

    Debbie Douglas on disgraced breast surgeon Ian Paterson

  17. Breast surgeon 'should suffer' - victimpublished at 15:49 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    One of the women wounded by breast surgeon Ian Paterson says he "should suffer and he should spend a long time in jail".

    Debbie DouglasImage source, Douglas Family

    Birmingham woman Debbie Douglas was a former patient who attended court proceedings, but did not give evidence.

    She had an unnecessary mastectomy which left her in "horrendous" pain and later learned her cancer was not serious enough to warrant such a procedure, or the exhausting seven-month course of chemotherapy she endured. 

    Quote Message

    Thank God those brave people who spoke up in court have got the right verdict."

    Debbie Douglas, Paterson patient

  18. Victim's breast cut 27 times 'for no good reason'published at 15:39 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A victim of Ian Paterson has told how he cut into her breast 27 times to carry out biopsies "for no good reason".

    Frances PerksImage source, GAVIN DICKSON

    Frances Perks had already lost her mother and sister to breast cancer when she was referred to the surgeon in 1994 after discovering a lump. 

    She was then advised to have a double mastectomy or risk "full blown cancer". 

    In the end, she opted to have one breast, her left, removed, and underwent eight other operations at Spire Parkway Hospital in Solihull after Paterson said he kept finding "sinister" looking lumps.  

  19. Recap: Breast surgeon whose needless procedures wounded patientspublished at 15:29 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    Here's a recap of the main points in the case of breast surgeon Ian Paterson who has been convicted this afternoon of wounding patients in a series of needless procedures.

    - Ian Paterson, 59, of Greater Manchester, has been found guilty of 17 counts of wounding with intent

    - He has also been convicted of three counts of unlawful wounding 

    - They relate to nine women and one man

    - A seven-week trial heard their accounts - representing a sample of those Paterson treated - of operations carried out between 1997 and 2011 at the private Little Aston and Parkway hospitals in the West Midlands 

    - Jurors have decided the surgeon carried out "extensive, life-changing operations for no medically-justifiable reason"

    - He has been granted bail and is due to be sentenced in May

  20. Paterson told victim cancer was 'inevitable'published at 15:19 British Summer Time 28 April 2017

    A victim of breast surgeon Ian Paterson who mutilated patients in unnecessary procedures says he told her she would inevitably get cancer. 

    Marian Moran was 49 in 1998 when she went to see her GP about a lump in her breast. A mammogram proved inconclusive, but Paterson removed a growth similar to a wart which did not reveal any signs of malignancy. 

    He then carried out further similar operations in 2001 and 2003, with the surgeon claiming the growths were pre-cancerous. 

    Mrs Moran then underwent a mastectomy in 2004.