House of Commons
Parliament

Tory MP Ken Clarke says it is is not possible to leave a free trade area and introduce tariff barriers, customs delays and delays at borders "without making this country poorer than it otherwise would be".

"It's difficult to see how anyone who studies economic policy can argue the contrary whilst keeeping a straight face," he adds.

He asks Mr Stride to confirm that the withdrawal agreement means no changes at all can be made to trading arrangements through March next year, "until we go into the transition period in which we can introduce practically any trading arrangements we want".

"It's obvious to me we should stay in the single market and the custom's union," he adds, and asks if Mr Stride can assure him that this is a possibility.

Financial Secretary to the Treasury Mel Stride says '"the deal is the best deal that delivers for this country going forwards."

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell says the least MPs could have expected is for the chancellor to come and respond the the UQ.

He says that the assessments are largely on the Chequers proposals, which were abandoned months ago.

The government is still "recklessly threatening" leaving without a deal, he says, which the analysis shows would reduce GDP by 11%.

He asks for confirmation that leaving without a deal is not an option that the government would allow to happen. He also asks if the government done any analysis of proposed backstop arrangements and whether they will be published, as well as about potential analysis on Article 50.

The government is not putting the economy and jobs first, he says.

Mel Stride says the chancellor will appear before the Treasury select committee, with the PM appearing before the Liaison Committee this week.

Analysis of Chequers is "entirely appropriate", he says, as the political declaration suggests a spectrum of arrangements.

Labour are pushing the UK closer to a no deal scenario, he says, for their own political reasons, whereas the government has reached a deal that secures the economic good of the country and delivers on Brexit vote.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, HoC

MPs have now moved onto today's urgent question from shadow chancellor John McDonnell on the government’s economic and fiscal analysis of Brexit scenarios.

Today the government released economic analysis of Brexit which compares the likely impact of the proposals agreed by the Cabinet at Chequers in July and set out in the government's White Paper, with the alternative scenarios of Norway-style membership of the European Economic Area, a Canada-style free trade agreement with the EU and a no-deal Brexit.

Financial Secretary to the Treasury Mel Stride says the government economic analysis forecast published today "does not prejudge all future policy or future worldwide economic changes".

He says the analysis shows that "the outcomes for the proposed future EU and UK relationship would deliver a higher economic output than a no deal scenario."

He says a no deal Brexit would create lower economic activity "across all areas of the UK" than the the proposed deal.

Mr Stride says the analysis "shows the deal on the table is the best deal and honours the referendum".

Mark D'Arcy
Parliamentary Correspondent

Direct defiance from Brexiteer Anne Marie Trevelyan in her call for a “clean global Brexit”.

I’m intrigued by the PM’s answer about “going back to square one” if her Brexit deal is rejected.

The PM’s warnings have previously included warnings of “no deal” or even “no Brexit".

Now she’s hinting at some kind of restart of the talks.

House of Commons
Parliament

Labour MP Liz Kendall says she's never heard any minister say that their government's plans will make the country poorer, but that's what the chancellor said this morning.

"Is that what the prime minister came into politics for?" she asks.

Mrs May says the Brexit deal that delivers best for British jobs and the economy is the deal reached.

House of Commons
Parliament

Conservative MP Peter Bone quotes from a Lords EU committee report that the Article 50 process enables the UK to leave the EU "without being liable for any outstanding financial obligations".

He says that two weeks ago the PM told him "completely the opposite". "Who is right?" he asks.

Mrs May says the committee "did say that" but there is "a different opinion on this, and that is that there are legal obligations" on Brexit, including payments.

She says the UK is "a country that fulfils its obligations".

House of Commons
Parliament

Independent MP Charlie Elphicke says there has recently been an unprecedented number of migrants entering the UK, crossing the Channel on unsafe craft.

He asks if the prime minister agrees that it's important Britain and France work together to find the people traffickers, put a stop to this and spend more on border security.

Theresa May says it's been agreed that a co-ordination point will be set up to co-ordinate French and British forces working on this.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, European photopress Agency

Tory MP Zac Goldsmith says it has been widely reported that fearing a backlash in the UK, the prime minister personally intervened to stop the government offering sanctuary to Asia Bibi the Pakistani Christian mother who "faces a very serious threat to her life".

Asia Bibi was convicted in 2010 of insulting the Prophet Muhammad during a row with neighbours, and many are calling for the reinstatement of the death penalty following her acquittal.

He asks the prime minister to take this opportunity to put the record straight "and to do everything she can to help that mother".

Theresa May says Mr Goldsmith "shouldn't necessarily believe everything he reads in the papers".

She says the position of the government is very clear, and "the prime concern has to be the safety of Asia Bibi and her family, and we want to see a swift resolution of the situation."

"We are working with other countries to make sure our prime aim which is the safety of Asia Bibi and her family is what is provided for."

House of Commons
Parliament

Conservative MP Anne Main asks if the PM will support more recycling centres being built in the UK to stop exports of waste and pass a law to "ban us exporting our rubbish to other countries where it often ends up in landfill or the ocean".

Theresa May says she hopes Anne Main "recognises the action the government has taken" and that she met owners of a small business yesterday in Wales, who have been selling products made of recycled plastic for almost 30 years.

She calls them an example of the "right thing to do today".

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

Lib Dem leader Sir Vince Cable says Parliament will prevent a no deal Brexit, even if the deal is rejected, and asks for an assurance from the PM that there is no reason for the public to be alarmed by the thought of no deal, as it will not happened.

Theresa May says backing the deal provides certainty for the UK, whilst failure to back it would lead to "chaos and uncertainty".

People don't want that chaos and don't want that uncertainty, she says.

House of Commons
Parliament

Labour MP Dame Louise Ellman says the chancellor has broadcast this morning that Brexit will make the UK "slightly worse off", that a last minute concession "puts Gibraltar's status on the line" and that "the effect on trade is unknown".

She calls for Article 50 to be extended and asks "isn't it time for a People's Vote?"

The prime minister says "the UK has absolutely stood by Gibraltar and we will continue to do so"; however "in terms of a second referendum, it's important that we deliver on the decision of the people."

She says it would "not be possible to have another referendum before March 29th" as Article 50 would have to be extended.

Theresa May says "the best option is to leave with a good deal that protects jobs across the country."

House of Commons
Parliament

Conservative MP Sir David Amess asks if the PM agrees that her proposed EU withdrawal deal "threatens our Union" and "has a distinct Remain flavour".

"I don't quite share his analysis of the deal that we've put forward," says Mrs May, but it "does protect our United Kingdom" as well as protecting jobs, ending free movement, cutting money sent to the EU and delivering on the vote of June 2016.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

SNP MP Douglas Chapman says he's horrified by the "arrogant, shambolic and non-inclusive" approach taken by the government in the Brexit negotiations.

He asks what the PM has learnt so the process can be improved when Scotland gets independence.

Mrs May says he'll be aware that Scotland voted to remain part of the UK.

The government has been working with devolved administrations, she says, "the voice of the devolved administrations has been heard".

House of Commons
Parliament

Labour MP Tracy Brabin raises the issue of historic abuse in the Church of England which, she says, could have been prevented if a "mandatory reporting" law had been in place.

She says evidence from around the world suggests it doubles the number of children put in a "place of safety" to escape abuse, and asks if the PM will back laws to introduce "mandatory reporting" rules into "all institutions".

Theresa May says that "too much abuse was allowed to carry on for too long" and that for those who were abused "suffering remains with them to this day".

She says the government "did look at this very carefully" but there is "mixed evidence". She says there's "some evidence that it can actually lead to genuine cases not being given the resources they require" but says no-one should doubt the "seriousness with which I and this government take this issue".

House of Commons
Parliament

Conservative MP Anne-Marie Trevelyan says with any divorce proceedings if a fair and equitable decision cannot be reached "they go to a judge for a decision".

In this case, she says, "Parliament must be the judge."

Ms Trevelyan asks if the prime minister agrees that once Parliament has rejected the deal "the UK would be better off setting the money aside to prepare for a clean global Brexit."

Theresa May says backing this deal means we will control our own borders, end free movement, create more jobs and can create trade deals around the world.

She says "if we reject this deal we go back to square one which threatens our economy and there will be more uncertainty and divisions."

"The choice is between backing the national interest or going back to square one if it is rejected," she clarifies.