House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

SNP Westminster leader Ian Blackford says the government's economic analysis shows that real wages will fall under the Brexit deal.

He asks if the PM agrees that the deal will leave people poorer than the status quo.

Theresa May says the analysis does not show that. It shows that the UK economy is strong and will continue to grow.

Mr Blackford questions whether she has read her own analysis.

He accuses her of wanting to take the UK back to the days of Thatcher and "believes unemployment is the price worth paying".

The people of Scotland voted overwhelmingly to remain, he says - they want their rights to be respected and will not give up their rights. He calls on the prime minister to explain why she wants to agree a deal that will rob Scotland of their rights as EU citizens.

The PM says there 3.3 million jobs have been created since the Tories came into power, with employment rate at near record high.

She says the people of Scotland voted to remain part of the United Kingdom and elected 13 Tory MPs.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

On the Brexit legal advice Jeremy Corbyn says MPs "need to see that advice, warts and all" so that an "informed decision" can be made.

He goes on to question the ability of the government to negotiate a full agreement with the EU between March 2019 and the end of the transition period given two years negotiating the exit deal marked by chaos and resignations.

He says it's "clear that Parliament will not back this plan" and says it's time for the PM to "accept that reality, make way for an alternative plan that can work for the whole country".

Theresa May says she "will take no lectures" from someone who had more than "one hundred resignations" from his frontbench.

She says that "what really lies behind Labour's approach" is a desire to "cause chaos, frustrate Brexit and overturn the will of the British people...that would be a betrayal of the many by the few".

Image source, hoc

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

Jeremy Corbyn says Parliament voted for the government to publish its legal advice in full, "yet the government today says it will ignore the sovereign will of Parliament".

He says in 2007 Theresa May wrote to the then prime minister saying the legal advice for the Iraq war should have been published in full, and asks if Theresa May if she plans to practice what she preaches.

Theresa May says "we have been clear legal guidance will be given and we will make a reasoned statement laying out the government's decision."

"The attorney general is willing to aid members by making a statement and answering oral questions," she adds.

House of Commons
Parliament

Jeremy Corbyn says if the government is responsible for good management of the economy, why are there 14 million people people in the UK living in poverty?

He says more than 200 chief executives and entrepreneurs have described the Brexit deal as "the worst of all worlds", whilst a private CBI email says "it's not a good deal".

All the PM can commit to is "working to frictionless trade", but she's only offering friction and less trade he says.

There's no confidence in trade negotiations being concluded in just two years, he says.

What's preferable, extending Article 50 or falling into the backstop with no exit? he asks.

Theresa May says there is an exit from the backstop and no one wants it to be invoked in the first place.

The EU cannot agree and sign a trade arrangement with an EU member while still in the union, she says, and that's why there is currently just the political declaration.

The December joint report was 16 pages long, she says, and it took less than a year to turn that into 500 pages of legal text - there's no reason they can't do that with the political declaration.

Everyone has repeatedly said we can't things it, she says, we've provided them wrong.

Where does Jeremy Corbyn's party stand if MPs vote against Theresa May's Brexit plan?

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

Jeremy Corbyn says that "after eight years of making our economy weaker through austerity" a "botched Brexit threatens to do the same".

He then quotes from a UN poverty report saying that, in meetings with ministers, they appeared to see the effect of Brexit on the poorest as an "afterthought".

He says MPs are "queuing up not to back the plan".

Theresa May says famers in Wales, fishermen in Scotland and employers in Northern Ireland are backing the plan.

She says MPs must realise the "importance of us delivering on Brexit" and "doing it in a way that protects jobs".

She goes on to defend her government's record on jobs staying workless households are at a record low.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, hoc

Leader of the opposition Jeremy Corbyn says "it's not hard to be the best deal if it's the only deal, and therefore by definition it's also the worst deal."

He says the government economic survey forecast published today is "meaningless" as there is no deal to model the analysis on, "just a wishlist".

Refering to the Chancellor Philip Hammond saying the UK would be "slightly worse off" under the prime minister's deal earlier this morning, Jeremy Corbyn asks if Theresa May agrees with his remarks.

He also notes that the chancellor "doesn't seem to be here to be consulted".

Theresa May says "the analysis shows the deal we have negotiated is the best deal for the economy and delivers on the results of the referendum.

"He calls the political declaration a wish list, but this is an ambitious, broad and flexible partnership," she adds.

"The Labour party has six bullet points to offer, my shopping list is longer than that."

House of Commons
Parliament

Jeremy Corbyn pays tribute to Baroness Trumpington, as well as his "friend" campaigner Harry Leslie Smith, who passed away last night.

He says the foreign secretary has said the Brexit deal mitigates "most of the negative impacts" of Brexit. He asks the PM which of the negative impacts it doesn't mitigate.

Theresa May says the analysis shows that the deal is the best deal available for jobs and the economy, while honoring referendum. It doesn't show that the UK will be worse off, she says.

The biggest risk to the economy are Jeremy Corbyn's policies, she adds.

Mark D'Arcy
Parliamentary Correspondent

Quite a gentle fisheries question from Douglas Ross – giving the PM a chance to offer some reassurance that she did not intend to trade away the rights of the fishing industry

The PM’s Scottish MPs know they are vulnerable on this.

And they provided the top-up of Commons seats which kept the Conservatives viable as a minority government, so they remain vital to Tory fortunes.

House of Commons
Parliament

Conservative Douglas Ross praises the PM for her "work ethic" in reaching a deal with the EU, but he says there are concerns many have, which he shares.

What guarantees can she give MPs who have concerns about the fishing industry, and of the union? he asks.

I am a committed unionist as he is, she tells the Moray MP.

"We will become an independent coastal state," she says, about fishing, and the UK will be determining access to our waters.

House of Commons
Parliament

Theresa May is on her feet for the question session with MPs.

She pays tribute to Baroness Trumpington, who died this week. The prime minister remembers her service at Bletchley as a codebreaker during World War II.

Mark D'Arcy
Parliamentary Correspondent

“Dum de dum de dum….Backstop....der de dur de dur....People’s Vote.... diddle diddle dee....jobs first....”

The prime minister’s Groundhog Day in the Commons rolls on, with the same people asking the same Brexit questions in the forlorn hope of suddenly extracting a different answer.

This edition of PMQs is just a continuation of the series of Commons grillings Theresa May has endured over the last fortnight… with the extra-hot seasoning provided by the strong expectation of a government defeat in the “Meaningful Vote” debate, in just under a fortnight’s time.

All the Brexit factions, eagle eyed, will be studying every syllable of the PM’s replies to those familiar questions, and vast speculative edifices will be erected on even the slightest variation in phrase or emphasis.

The batting order for this PMQs is heavy with Labour MPs, which means plenty of Conservatives will be “bobbing” in the hope of being called as the Speaker seeks to even up the numbers between government and opposition – and that gives the various party factions the chance to get their points in….

The loyalists will be talking about Small Business Saturday, doubtless with a segue to the benefits of the government’s Brexit deal; the dissidents on the Remain side may have something to say about the newly-published economic forecasts, and the Leavers will want to rubbish them.

Brexiteers Anne Marie Trevelyan and Theresa Villiers are on the list of questioners.

And watch out too for the Scottish Conservatives, caught in an uncomfortable political trap on the issue of EU access to UK fisheries, after Brexit…. Douglas Ross, MP for Moray, is one of the Scottish Tories whose future is on the line over this, and he is listed to ask a question.

An interesting sub-plot is that the shadow chancellor John McDonnell has secured an urgent question on those economic forecasts, after PMQs.

This makes it less likely that Jeremy Corbyn will major on them - although he might decide to provide a warm-up.

And then there’s the Chancellor himself. Philip Hammond is not down to respond to the UQ, which could mean he has to slink out of the chamber at the end of PMQs, doubtless to shouts of derision from Labour….

Or maybe he will give the entire session a miss? That’s not a good look either.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, HoC

Asked by SNP MP Douglas Chapman what discussions he's had with the prime minister on the effect on Scotland of the UK leaving the EU, David Mundell says "the deal is a deal for all parts of the UK" and will protect jobs right across the country.

If the SNP don't want to see disruption after Brexit then they should back the prime minister's deal, he says.

He says he won't take advice from the SNP on protecting the Scottish economy when they want to take Scotland out of its strongest market - with the rest of the UK.

The Scottish people will be asking why the SNP are so keen on forcing a no deal Brexit, he says.

There's jostling among parliamentarians over space in one of Westminster's favourite watering holes.

House of Commons
Parliament

Image source, HoC

Conservative MP Paul Masterton gets the Commons day started, asking about talks between the UK and Scottish governments on the granting of legislative consent motions for Brexit legislation. He asks the Scotland secretary to urge the Scottish government to stop playing political games with important legislation.

Scotland Secretary David Mundell says the government is fully committed to the Sewel convention, external and the related practices and procedures for seeking legislative consent.

SNP MP Patrick Grady says the government's actions suggests they are actually more interested in undermining the Sewel convention.

Mr Mundell says the SNP are more interested in undermining the United Kingdom that protecting the interests of Scotland.