Manchester United

Image source, Getty Images

We asked for your thoughts after Manchester United's thrilling Europa League quarter-final win over Lyon on Thursday.

Here are some of your comments:

Kenny: That, my friends, is Manchester United in a nutshell - absolutely crazy.

Andy: In extra time at two goals down, we were out of Europe and staring into the abyss. Fans in the stadium were leaving in their droves and those watching at home were wondering whether Ruben Amorim would survive as manager. Minutes later, we'd created one of the most iconic European nights in the history of Old Trafford. Could this be the catalyst for better things to come?

Neil: Great comeback and a sensational game - but, as a United fan, we must not forget that this team is still lacking quality for the Premier League. Very much need a quality striker. Onwards and upwards to the final!

Iain: Was it Moments FC again, saving us from disaster? Of course. Was it enjoyable? Absolutely! If you can't enjoy a positive result like that, even with the criticism that follows, you have lost your way as a Manchester United fan. Sure, there are problems with the ownership, but that was pits of despair to cloud nine on the pitch. Massive smile still on my face!

Alex: Harry Maguire has to be the story here. Written off for years, got his head down and fought back into the squad and system - vital player, first-choice centre-back again, scores the winning goal. If that isn't mentality, I don't know what is.

Max: For all the sentiment and celebration at reaching the semi-finals, let's be real. We were minutes away from humiliation against opposition with 10 men. The red card and extra time bailed us out. All that aside, I am delighted for Amorim and this win should be for him. As for some of the rest... embarrassing throwing that 2-0 lead away.

There was great joy among United fans at full-time, although some may have left Old Trafford or turned off their television a little early when Lyon's fourth goal went in during extra time.

Did you miss the late drama? And if so, how are you feeling today?

Let us know

Image source, Daily Express/Daily Star

Manchester United's progression to the Europa League semi-finals looked almost assured when Diogo Dalot's goal gave them a 2-0 lead over Lyon at Old Trafford.

Image source, PA Media

But back came the French club with two second-half goals to take the tie to extra time.

Image source, PA Media

Despite Corentin Tolisso being sent off in the 89th minute, it was Lyon who took control in extra time - Alexandre Lacazette's penalty putting the visitors 4-2 up.

Image source, PA Media

Hopes of silverware this season gone?

Image source, PA Media

Then the comeback started. A Bruno Fernandes penalty gave United hope. They couldn't, could they?

Image source, PA Media

Kobbie Mainoo equalised before Harry Maguire sent Old Trafford delirious with a stoppage-time winner.

Image source, PA Media

Image source, PA Media

Image source, PA Media

Simon Stone
Chief football news reporter

Image source, PA Media

Sometimes, it is pointless trying to make sense of this game.

Sir Alex Ferguson's famous "football, bloody hell" comment after the 1999 Champions League final victory over Bayern Munich, which featured two injury-time goals to win it, sprang to mind as Harry Maguire headed off down the tunnel at the end of the thrilling Europa League win over Lyon.

United boss Ruben Amorim responded to his goal by chasing off down the touchline, just as Jose Mourinho famously did when Porto won in this stadium in 2004. Rio Ferdinand, commentating for TNT Sports, was shown jumping up and down with delight.

Most Manchester United fans would have felt the same.

In the cold light of day, United still have a semi-final to play - and, possibly, an all-English final against Tottenham - before they can claim a Champions League place by winning the Europa League and grabbing some silverware to at least make this desperate campaign a success.

But it will be a while before the memories of what happened fade.

The plans are to replace this stadium, that is over 100 years old and has played host to the Busby Babes - the only other United side to win a game by a 5-4 scoreline when they beat Arsenal in the match before the Munich tragedy - the Holy Trinity of George Best, Denis Law and Bobby Charlton, Double and Treble winners, Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney.

This team are not a patch on those. But this single game stands alongside any those illustrious predecessors produced as one of the very best.

Catch up with all of the reaction on BBC Radio 5 Live's Football Daily podcast as Manchester United and Tottenham Hotspur secure their spots in the last four of this season's Europa League.

Listen to the full episode on BBC Sounds

Simon Stone
Chief football news reporter

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester United defenders Noussair Mazraoui and Victor Lindelof had to leave Old Trafford on Thursday to attend to urgent family issues.

Mazraoui did not appear for the second half after starting the 5-4 victory over Lyon. Lindelof appeared to be getting ready to come on but, in the end, the change never materialised.

Both issues were independent of each other and United sources said both players were fine.

Manchester United and Liverpool are among the clubs interested in signing Lyon's 21-year-old French forward Rayan Cherki this summer. (Mail - subscription required), external

United and Tottenham have held talks with Eintracht Frankfurt over the signing of 22-year-old Brazilian goalkeeper Kaua Santos. (Bild - in German), external

Atletico Madrid are interested in signing United's £70m-rated winger Alejandro Garnacho, but will face competition from Bayer Leverkusen. (Teamtalk), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Friday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

109 minutes: Manchester United 2-4 Lyon (4-6 agg)...

Image source, Getty Images

121 minutes: Manchester United 5-4 Lyon (7-6 agg)

Image source, Getty Images

Image source, Getty Images

"Disbelief" but a "special night" at Old Trafford.

That's the views of former Manchester United coach Rene Meulensteen and ex-England goalkeeper Paul Robinson after Ruben Amorim's side staged an incredible extra-time comeback against Lyon in their Europa League quarter-final second leg.

Speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live, Meulensteen said: "How many emotions do you have to go through?

"Manchester United were down and out. Credit where credit is due with Ruben Amorim.

"He puts Harry Maguire upfront, against the run of play Lyon go 4-2 up and with the penalty you think that's it.

"You could see Lyon crumbling, but credit to the way Kobbie Mainoo and Harry Maguire took their goals. Amazing.

"Everybody walks away in disbelief. Ruben Amorim couldn't get into the dressing room quick enough."

Robinson added: "A special night at Old Trafford. I don't think I have ever seen a game like that.

"Ruben Amorim coolly making his way off. They looked dead and buried. I have not seen that character from them all season.

"Superlatives, you run out of them - wow, wow, wow for what we've just seen.

"These Manchester United fans have been starved of this for too long."

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim, speaking to TNT Sports: "I was watching the 1999 [Treble] documentary to have some inspiration for these moments.

"It was a great night, the team were tired, 4-2 with one more player, we think it's over, but here it's never over.

"Here everything is possible, you feel the environment. At 4-3, after the Bruno Fernandes penalty, we felt we could change the game."

On his substitutions: "We tried to put Harry Maguire up front because he is the only one who can score a goal with a header. Kobbie Mainoo has a lack of pace in this moment because of injury, but he's really good in short spaces."

On Europa League focus: "One moment can change a lot of things in the players' minds, we have to be really focused on Europa League and take risks sometimes with kids in Premier League. Fans have to understand that, we have to focus on the Europa League."

On hopes of winning the competition: "Everybody in this moment believes it is possible, we need luck with injuries.

On what he thought when Maguire score: "The sounds of the stadium was the best ever. Some people collect shirts, scarves, but I want to keep that sound, it's the best sound in the world.

"I feel for the people who had to leave at 4-2 because of the traffic, they will be gutted.

"We know we are underperforming and deserve all the critics, but we have time to make something special of this season"

On United's performances in Europe: "We must recognise the context, we lack a lot of characteristics in our team, physicality is a problem.

"When we play against European teams we can cope better with that, in Premier League we suffer a lot."

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester United match-winner Harry Maguire, speaking to TNT Sports: "Obviously it's an incredible game, we made really hard work of it.

"We had full control in the second half, had chances to score a third, then they scored out of nowhere. It put us on the back foot.

"To go down 4-2 in extra-time to 10 men is not good enough, we opened ourselves too much. But we dug in and showed great spirit, that's what this stadium does."

On his goal: "I felt like the fourth goal for them was a sucker punch but that we'd get chances to get back into it. It fell to myself and thankfully I scored, it was an amazing feeling."

On if he fouled the defender: "He was back-pedalling but I just held him there, with my hand, there was no where near enough for a foul."

Image source, Getty Images

Harry Maguire's goal was the first 120th minute winning goal scored in Europa League history and the first in a major European tie since Atletico Madrid beat Liverpool at Anfield in March 2020.

This match was also the first game in major European football history to see five goals scored in extra-time.

Meanwhile, United have now won as many matches in the Europa League under Ruben Amorim (six wins in eight games) as they have in 21 Premier League matches under him (W6 D5 L10).

Were you at the game or following from elsewhere?

Have your say on Man Utd's performance

Come back to this page on Friday to find a selection of your replies

Chelsea, Manchester United and Tottenham are all involved in a busy evening of European football on Thursday and BBC Sport will bring you every kick.

All kick-off times 20:00 BST unless stated

Europa League:

• Athletic Bilbao v Rangers (agg 0-0)

• Frankfurt v Tottenham (agg 1-1)

• Lazio v Bodo/Glimt (agg 0-2)

• Man Utd v Lyon (agg 2-2) - listen on BBC Radio 5 Live

Conference League:

• Fiorentina v Celje (17:45 BST - agg 2-1)

• Jagiellonia v Real Betis (17:45 BST - agg 0-2)

• Chelsea v Legia Warsaw (agg 3-0)

• Rapid Vienna v Djurgarden (agg 1-0)

Follow all of the action and reaction

Image source, Getty Images

We asked for your views on if Manchester United and Ruben Amorim should prepare any differently to normal for tonight's game against Lyon. And if so, how?

Here are some of your comments:

Peter: Use a formation that they are familiar with. Drop the experiments for this season and try to stabilise for the rest of this season.

Mike: A Tifo and fireworks, how very Championship. I know that my response is sneery, but the fact is that the manager and players are responsible for improving the atmosphere at Old Trafford.

We create it, they respond with a passionate performance, we respond, it's a virtuous circle that every match going fan is familiar with. Unfortunately our manager and players have catastrophically broken the loop, so the club is reduced to these second rate, small time carnival tricks. Pathetic.

Graham: The players we have right now don't seem to care. Even Fernandes, he is there to pick the other players up as captain not sulk like a child. Amorim needs to do a big rebuild this summer and get rid of the deadwood, Rashford, Zirkzee, Hojlund and Sancho. Get them sold and get hungrier players and a new captain!

Ken: A tifo banner will be embarrassing for a club like Man Utd. It's an admission that as well as not being good enough on the field, they're not good enough off the field either.

Image source, Getty Images

I can see the reasons behind Ruben Amorim taking Andre Onana out of the Manchester United team for the defeat at Newcastle, but I believe he should go back into the team for Thursday's Europa League quarter-final second leg against Lyon.

Removing Onana from the squad completely allowed him to have a break from the limelight and potentially reflect on recent performances - and ill-judged comments before the first leg in France.

It also took away the chance for the television cameras to pick him out whenever replacement Altay Bayindir was under any sort of pressure. This was the case when Mikel Arteta was phasing out Aaron Ramsdale in favour of David Raya at Arsenal but did not commit to one being first choice.

This is why it is important for managers to have a clear number one and why Onana should play against Lyon. He was bought in for big money from Inter Milan when a lot of big clubs were interested in him and that was for a reason - to be first choice.

Keeping Onana out any longer would kill his confidence and it is clear Bayindir is a second choice goalkeeper who is carrying his own nerves.

However, I think it is clear United need to recruit a new goalkeeper in the summer. Onana is not a bad goalkeeper by any means but his confidence and presence has been eroded over time and to come back from that at a club like Manchester United is very hard, with the levels of pressure and scrutiny.

There is no guarantee a new goalkeeper would not also fall victim to the state of the club, but there is a better chance of someone new succeeding under an Amorim rebuild than Onana, who carries the baggage of a difficult two seasons.

Fara Williams was speaking to BBC Sport's Nat Hayward

Dale O'Donnell
Fan writer

Image source, Getty Images

Manchester United changing their pre-match routine should inspire a big performance from Ruben Amorim's team against Lyon in the Europa League quarter-final second leg.

A European night under the floodlights awaits at Old Trafford and the club will unveil a first-ever tifo banner in front of the Sir Alex Ferguson Stand in an attempt to enhance the famous atmosphere that should inspire the team.

There is no need to change team hotel, like Newcastle did in the Carabao Cup final, because United are used to bigger occasions than this, but that does not take away from the fact our 2024-25 campaign will end prematurely if we do not win later.

The United players should be aware that many of these fans have travelled across the country and Europe with them this season, and the results have been nowhere near good enough. It is time they took responsibility and gave something back to the Old Trafford faithful.

Along with the tifo being displayed before kick-off, red and white pyrotechnics will appear adjacent to the banner, in a larger display than seen against Real Sociedad in the last 16.

It promises to be a big night at Old Trafford.

Find more from Dale O'Donnell at United In Focus, external

What do you think? Should United and Ruben Amorim prepare any differently to normal for a game of this magnitude? And if so, how?

Let us know

RB Leipzig are expected to set an £86m asking price for 21-year-old Slovenia striker Benjamin Sesko, who is attracting interest from Manchester United, Chelsea and Arsenal. (Bild - in German), external

Ruben Amorim's side have identified RB Leipzig's 21-year-old Netherlands forward Xavi Simons as a summer target - but the club's transfer plans are likely to hinge on Champions League qualification. (Mail - subscription required), external

Sporting are open to summer offers for 23-year-old Portugal defender and United target Goncalo Inacio. (A Bola - in Portuguese), external

Marcus Rashford hopes his improved form on loan at Aston Villa will attract interest from top European teams, with United unlikely to welcome him back in the summer. (Talksport), external

The Red Devils have already started to draw up a shortlist of potential replacements for Rashford, with Villa uncertain whether to take up the option to sign the forward for £40m. (Sky Sports), external

Meanwhile, another season out on loan for Rashford is not being ruled out as an option. (Times - subscription required), external

Want more transfer stories? Read Thursday's full gossip column

Follow the gossip column on BBC Sport

Simon Stone
Chief football news reporter

Image source, Getty Images

Lyon manager Paulo Fonseca is bracing himself for Manchester United's "best performance of the season" at Old Trafford on Thursday.

United face the Ligue 1 side in the Europa League quarter-final second-leg knowing victory is essential if they are to qualify for next season's Champions League.

In what has been a desperate campaign domestically, United have already lost at home to Crystal Palace, Brighton, Newcastle, Bournemouth and Nottingham Forest amongst others. In addition, they were knocked out of the FA Cup by Fulham on penalties at Old Trafford.

However, Fonseca is not reading too much into those results.

He knows United's season is hanging in the balance and is expecting a highly motivated opponent.

"I expect Manchester United's strongest performance of the season," he said.

"They are a big team and a big club. True, in the Premier League they are not what they were. It has been a bit different, but in the Europa League they have put in some good performances and have a lot of individual skills.

"I expect to be playing against the best United there is. It is a decisive moment for Manchester United. They will be super motivated for the match."