1. Subdued at Selhurstpublished at 21:13 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer at Selhurst Park

    Selhurst Park is normally a bear pit but - baiting of referee Craig Pawson aside - it has been very low-key here.

    In defence of what are normally very fervent fans, Palace's approach has been so passive that they have given their supporters nothing to get behind.

    Alan PardewImage source, Getty Images
  2. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 21:11 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Text 81111

    Ben, London: Rojo should have seen red! Terrible refereeing once again, blatant two footed tackle! Does Mourinho not warn his players against stupidity? 

    Degan, a disillusioned football fan: I hate diving and all the nonsense which goes on in modern football, but if the refs can't even see a blatant two-footed lunge then what's their purpose!?

  3. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 52 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Bad news for United as Eric Bailly is unable to continue. He has been in the wars tonight and he takes an age to hobble off the pitch to be replaced by Matteo Darmian.

    Eric BaillyImage source, PA
  4. Postpublished at 50 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    United are still very comfortable in possession. Apart from Joe Ledley's earlier effort, Palace have offered little to nothing.

  5. Postpublished at 21:07 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Steve Claridge
    Ex-Leicester striker at Selhurst Park, BBC Radio 5 live

    You can look at this game in two ways. 

    One is that Palace have got what they deserve having not threatened or you could say that they have defended well.

  6. CLOSE!published at 47 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    A first touch by Joe Ledley almost results in an equaliser. The Wales midfielder lets fly from outside the area - and it's only just wide. That's woken the Palace fans up!

  7. KICK-OFFpublished at 46 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Alan Pardew responds to Palace's poor first half by sending on Joe Ledley for Mathieu Flamini at the start of the second half. Palace need to respond. They have been poor so far.

  8. The stats don't liepublished at 21:00 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    HT: Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Manchester United have really dominated the first-half possession against Palace, who failed to register a shot on target.

    .
  9. Postpublished at 21:00 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Steve Claridge
    Ex-Leicester striker at Selhurst Park, BBC Radio 5 live

    Zlatan Ibrahimovic was not marked and that is why Palace have been punished.

    There was an element of offside but Palace will be disappointed.

  10. get involved

    United fortunate to be ahead?published at 20:57 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    #bbcfootball

    Rob Jones: Ibra punches it to and offside Pogba and the goal stands the refs shocking!!

    Luke: United the most lucky team in PL history. Anyone who believes JM's outlandish claims are as pathetic as him!

    Matt Collingwood: United very lucky to go in a goal up at the break. Even luckier to finish the half with 11 men!

  11. Manchester United enjoying good fortunepublished at 20:56 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer at Selhurst Park

    A dull first 45 minutes ends in acrimony with Crystal Palace furious after appeals for handball and offside were ignored as Zlatan Ibrahimovic appeared to handle a pass into Paul Pogba's path for his goal.

    And what about Marcos Rojo? Will he ever learn? So fortunate to escape a red card for a two-footed lunge on Idrissa Gueye at Everton - he does exactly the same thing on Wilfried Zaha and is lucky to just get a yellow card.

  12. 'Strange game'published at 20:52 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utd

    Steve Claridge
    Ex-Leicester striker at Selhurst Park, BBC Radio 5 live

    It has been a strange game, without any real tempo or gusto. 

    Palace have just looked to hit United on the break. There hasn't been any real blood and thunder.

  13. HALF-TIME - Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utdpublished at 20:47 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Three shots on target. One goal. Palace have shown little imagination.

  14. goal

    GOAL - Crystal Palace 0-1 Man Utdpublished at 45 mins

    Paul Pogba

    A scrappy goal gives United the lead in the scrappiest of games. Paul Pogba is in the right place to stroke the ball home from close range after Palace failed to deal with a free-kick. The home side claim Zlatan Ibrahimovic handled the ball in the build-up but United have the lead.

    Paul PogbaImage source, Reuters
  15. get involved

    Get Involved #bbcfootballpublished at 20:45 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    Did Man Utd's Rojo deserve a red card for his tackle on Wilfried Zaha?

    Peter Collins: Rojo should seen red there. Awful tackle. Again. Not learning.

    Richard: Rojo two footed again. When are refs going to grow a pair and send him off for it?

    Stephen James: Rojo should've been sent off there. Another two-footed tackle which Zaha did well to ride.Shocking challenge!

    Jay: Rojo you lucky boy!! He needs to stop doing 2 footed tackles. Got away with that one.

  16. CLOSE!published at 43 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    United have finally woken up. Paul Pogba's volley, after a wonderful ball by Michael Carrick, forces another save from Wayne Hennessey.

  17. YELLOW CARDpublished at 41 mins

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    First booking of the game and it's fully deserved. Marcos Rojo is cautioned after taking out Wilfried Zaha in full flight. That was poor by the United man.

    Marcos RojoImage source, Reuters
  18. 'Fantastic movement'published at 20:40 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    Steve Claridge
    Ex-Leicester striker at Selhurst Park, BBC Radio 5 live

    That is why you want Rooney in central areas. 

    It was fantastic movement in behind and he was unlucky with the shot.

  19. CLOSE!published at 20:40 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    It's taken 37 painful minutes but we have our first serious chance on goal.

    A lovely chip by Paul Pogba finds Wayne Rooney, deep inside the Palace penalty area, who forces a fine save from Wayne Hennessey.

  20. Postpublished at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 14 December 2016

    Crystal Palace 0-0 Man Utd

    Steve Claridge
    Ex-Leicester striker at Selhurst Park, BBC Radio 5 live

    Manchester United have some good players but there is a fragmented look about them.

    They have too many people that are not quite playing in the right position.

    Crystal Palace v Man UtdImage source, PA