Summary

  • Crewe of League Two knocked out third-tier Derby with 3-1 win at Pride Park

  • Fourth-tier Salford lost to League One side Peterborough in penalty shootout

  • Non-league Scarborough and Slough beaten heavily by EFL opposition

  • Seventh-tier Horsham conceded three early goals in 3-0 home loss to Barnsley

  • Second-round ties to be played on 1-4 December

  1. Postpublished at 21:20 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Derby 1-3 Crewe Alexandra

    As things stand, Derby are heading out and on course to be the highest-profile exit on this FA Cup first-round replay night.

  2. Postpublished at 90 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Into three minutes added on as seventh-tier Horsham's FA Cup odyssey comes to an end.

    They've given it a right go this half to try to get a goal for their vocal home support.

  3. Stunning Salford make it 3-3published at 21:15 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    #bbcfacup

    Peterborough could have been out of sight at half-time, but the League One side have conceded two goals in seven minutes and it is now 3-3 at Salford!

    Josh Knight's own goal has put the League Two hosts level.

    Meanwhile, Doncaster's Zain Westbrooke has found an equalising goal to make it 1-1 at fellow League Two team Accrington.

    York striker Lenell John-Lewis is the latest player to score twice on what has been an evening full of goals in the FA Cup.

    The National League side are now 2-1 up against sixth-tier Chester, with George Glendon netting to keep the visitors in the tie.

  4. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 86 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Nicky Cadden, who got things going for the away team inside three minutes tonight, is off and Owen Dodgson is on.

  5. goal

    GOAL: Grimsby 4-2 Sloughpublished at 21:13 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Arthur Gnahoua (65 mins)

    It's been all Slough but out of nowhere Grimsby get their fourth goal and a crucial two-goal buffer over their non-league opponents.

    Rekeil Pyke sends a cross into the box and picks out an oncoming Arthur Gnahoua who slots it into the bottom corner to make it 4-2.

    A cruel blow for Slough who have been on top for the majority of this second half so far.

  6. goal

    GOAL: Derby 1-3 Crewe Alexandrapublished at 21:10 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Mickey Demetriou (65 mins)

    Mickey Demetriou celebrates a goal for CreweImage source, PA Media

    Crewe fans are in dreamland as they increase their lead to two goals and that could well be that for Derby in the FA Cup this year.

    It's all too easy for the visitors as a corner comes in and Mickey Demetriou, unmarked at the near post, has a simple, free header into the net.

  7. Postpublished at 83 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    It'll be a trip to League Two's bottom side Sutton in the second round for Barnsley now.

    If they set about that tie as they did this you'd expect them to be in the hat for round three.

  8. Postpublished at 21:07 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Derby 1-2 Crewe Alexandra

    The possession is all going Crewe's way at the moment and Pride Park is falling quiet.

    Derby boss Paul Warne has made his first change of the night, bringing on winger Joe Ward in a bid to turn things around with 30 minutes left on the clock.

  9. Can Salford stay in the FA Cup?published at 21:06 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    #bbcfacup

    Curtis Tilt celebrates a goal for SalfordImage source, Getty Images

    A decade ago, Matt Smith's double for Oldham knocked Liverpool out of the FA Cup, but tonight the Salford striker has come off at half-time, to the surprise of the BBC Radio Manchester commentary team.

    Instead, the League Two side have found inspiration from a defender, as Curtis Tilt has halved the deficit against League One Peterborough with his second goal of the match.

    Darren Ferguson's team came from 1-0 down to look comfortable at half-time, but now Posh only lead 3-2 and this one looks far from over.

  10. Postpublished at 76 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Another chance for the Hornets!

    The ball is worked neatly down their left before a low cross to the near post for Daniel Ajakaiye.

    He makes decent contact but can't direct it on target.

    The home side then make a triple sub for the final 15 minutes.

  11. CLOSE!published at 21:03 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Grimsby 3-2 Slough

    That was almost 3-3!

    A second free-kick for Slough right on the edge of the box and while Harvey Cartwright clears the first effort in the Grimsby goal, it comes back into the box again and Danny Rose has to clear the ball off the line to keep it out.

    That's surely as close as it gets. Slough are really upping the pressure, here.

  12. Postpublished at 21:00 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Grimsby 3-2 Slough

    Slough are very much still in this game.

    They win a free-kick which is taken by Matt Lench and it's a high, looping ball that bounces around in the box before Grimsby eventually clear it.

    One touch and that could easily have gone in if it dropped in the right place.

  13. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 71 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Neill Collins stands on the touchlineImage source, Getty Images

    Barnsley manager Neill Collins make another brace of changes.

    Aiden Marsh and two-goal John McAtee are off, Max Watters and Sam Cosgrove are on at the top end of the pitch for the League One outfit.

  14. DISALLOWED GOALpublished at 20:58 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Grimsby 3-2 Slough Town

    Grimsby get the ball in the net but it won't count as Rekeil Pyke is quickly flagged offside.

    A warning sign for Slough if they want to get back in this match.

  15. Postpublished at 68 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    What an impact from sub Vimal Yoganathan for the Tykes.

    He twists and turns down their left and then hits a low cross in for Adam Phillips.

    His shot looks to be flying in but Lewis Carey makes a fine save in the home goal.

  16. Postpublished at 20:54 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    Derby 1-2 Crewe Alexandra

    Crewe have got 45 minutes to do something they haven't done since the 2000-01 season.

    That was the last time they knocked out an EFL side in an FA Cup replay, when they beat Cardiff City.

    So far they've got the crucial one-goal advantage that makes all the difference.

  17. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 66 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Vimal Yoganathan and Corey O'Keeffe are on for Luca Connell and Jordan Williams for the away side.

    They've been flat this half, albeit the tie is won.

  18. Postpublished at 64 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    The home side really fancy a goal!

    First Daniel Ajakaiye hits a tame effort at goalkeeper Ben Killip in the Barnsley goal and then sub Kadell Daniel sees a shot blocked for a corner.

    The delivery misses everyone in the box.

  19. Postpublished at 20:47 Greenwich Mean Time 14 November 2023

    #bbcfacup

    Paul Warne sits in the Derby dugoutImage source, PA Media

    We're almost back under way in our seven 19:45 GMT kick-offs.

    We'll be keeping a closer eye on events at Derby and Grimsby for the time being, but continuing to bring you news of all of the goals as they go in.

    Remember - you can listen to live BBC local radio commentary of seven of tonight's replays via the icons at the top of this page.

  20. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 58 mins

    Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    The home side go to the bench for the second time this evening.

    Kadell Daniel is on and Shamir Fenelon is off at the top end of the pitch for the non-league side.