Summary

  • Eighth-tier Cray Valley Paper Mills knocked out by League One Charlton

  • Charlton scored five goals after break having been level at half-time

  • Lisbie had levelled from spot for Cray Valley

  • 116 league places and five divisions separate the two sides

  • Charlton will visit League Two Gillingham in round two

  1. KICK-OFFpublished at 20:51 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Back under way.

    Are we 45 minutes away from Cray Valley's first-ever win in the FA Cup proper?

  2. SUBSTITUTIONpublished at 20:48 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Michael Appleton brings on Tyreece Campbell for Corey Blackett-Taylor as the teams trot out for the second half.

  3. 'They need more belief'published at 20:48 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    HT: Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Danny Murphy
    Former England midfielder on MOTD Live

    I think the Cray Valley manager will be telling his players to believe in yourself more with the ball.

    They've defended well and they've got a nice shape, but when they've got the ball they've lacked a bit of belief.

    They've got to get a bit more support for the front man and try and get up the pitch a bit, because it'll be a long second half if they play like they did in the first.

  4. Tuesday night round-uppublished at 20:46 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    FT: Horsham 0-3 Barnsley

    Media caption,

    FA Cup highlights: Professional Barnsley ease past Horsham in FA Cup

    There was no magic of the cup for non-leaguers Horsham on Tuesday night as they were ousted from the competition by League One side Barnsley.

    Scarborough Athletic and Slough Town also fell to league sides Forest Green and Grimsby respectively.

    You can check out all of the highlights from Tuesday's eight replays here.

  5. 'That pass has changed the game'published at 20:43 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    HT: Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Danny Murphy
    Former England midfielder on MOTD Live

    It's come from nowhere.

    Charlton had done alright in the game and controlled it quite well.

    Cray Valley defended reasonably well, but Charlton had got the goal, you could sense the relief in their play, they were keeping the ball.

    But that wonderful pass to put Lisbie in has changed the game and turned it on its head.

  6. Postpublished at 20:42 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    HT:Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    This will reignite the old VAR debate about the FA Cup.

    It's not employed in this competition at non-Premier League grounds.

    Replays suggest Charlton keeper Sam Walker's challenge on Kyrell Lisbie was outside the area.

    It wouldn't have been a penalty - but it might have been a red card rather than a yellow, so perhaps it evened itself out?

  7. 'I didn't watch it'published at 20:40 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    HT: Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Former Charlton striker Kevin Lisbie on BBC Two on his son Kyrell's penalty:

    "I didn't watch it (the penalty), but Danny told me that he scored.

    "He made a good run which I always tell him to do so he's got in behind the defence and got in front of the keeper and nice and brave as well.

    "I'm not sure what that stutter's about - I've never been a fan of that.

    "On an occasion like this to do that shows some guts because I wouldn't have done that, so fair play to him."

  8. May's 'top-class' touch and finish gives Charlton leadpublished at 20:38 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Media caption,

    FA Cup 2023: Charlton take the lead with 'top-class finish' from Alfie May

    The opener seems an age ago now - but what a cracking goal it was.

  9. HALF-TIMEpublished at 20:35 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Cray Valley celebrate equaliserImage source, Rex Features

    And breathe.

    It was all Charlton for the opening 35 minutes and when Alfie May tucked them ahead, a serene evening looked on the cards.

    But Kyrell Lisbie's penalty has really put the cat among the pigeons.

  10. Postpublished at 20:34 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Matthew Upson
    Former England defender on MOTD Live

    It looked offside to me, but look at the headers they're winning.

    Lee wins the first one and it's probably about a yard off, but very close.

  11. Postpublished at 45+2 mins

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Goodness me, the entire Artic Stadium holds its breath as Kyrell Lisbie races clear again...

    But this time he's halted by a marginal offside flag as the assistant sticks a pin in the balloon and lets all the air out of the atmosphere here in London.

  12. 'He's lucky to stay on the pitch'published at 20:31 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 1-1 Charlton

    Matthew Upson
    Former England defender on MOTD Live

    Talk about turning this cup tie on its head.

    But also, it has to be said, is it only a yellow card because it looks like a goalscoring opportunity.

    He clearly gets to the ball first and he kicks straight through him. He's lucky to stay on the pitch.

  13. goal

    GOAL: Cray Valley 1-1 Charltonpublished at 44 mins

    Kyrell Lisbie (pen)

    Kyrell Lisbie gives it the old stutter step, sees which way Sam Walker is going - and puts his penalty in the other direction.

    He brings the underdogs level against his dad's old team!

    Media caption,

    FA Cup 2023: Kyrell Lisbie penalty brings Cray Valley Paper Mills level

  14. YELLOW CARDpublished at 20:30 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Kyrell Lisbie goes through and gets the ball before Charlton keeper Sam Walker, who kicks him in the leg.

    It looks outside the area but a penalty is given. No VAR remember...

    The keeper's lucky to stay on the pitch to be fair... gets only a yellow.

  15. PENALTY TO CRAY VALLEYpublished at 43 mins

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Now then!

  16. Postpublished at 20:29 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Alfie May's heatmap shows what a danger he's been to Cray Valley....

    Oh hang on...

    TouchmapImage source, BBC Sport
  17. Postpublished at 20:28 Greenwich Mean Time 15 November 2023

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Matthew Upson
    Former England defender on MOTD Live

    Just to see that, let alone attempt it!

    It's falling out of the sky and such is his confidence he thinks he can just loop it over Freeman.

  18. Postpublished at 40 mins

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Oh, Alfie May's tail is up, all right.

    The ball drops out of the sky and, 35 yards out, he spots Cray keeper Sam Freeman off his line, and unleashes a volley that sails over the stopper but wide of the goal.

  19. Postpublished at 37 mins

    Cray Valley PM 0-1 Charlton

    Cray Valley go close to an instant response as Arthur Lee's towering header finds Matthew Vigor.

    He pulls the ball back for Sonny Black in the Charlton area but his shot is blocked and the Addicks crowd him out.