Richie Macca: This England team is like me: Not very good in the morning.

Howard Horner: OK, I know we should judge him on the bowling, not batting... But when do we start questioning Broad's place in the team?

Can England last the 50 or so minutes until lunch? Chris Jordan hasn't made it up the other end yet - he's exclusively faced his former Barbados team-mate Jason Holder so far. He finally rotates the strike with a single to mid-on, leaving Holder two deliveries to bowl to Anderson. He ducks a bouncer, before unleashing a perfectly-timed on-drive for four.

Anderson has eight - more importantly, he's three behind Sir Ian Botham's record total of 383 Test wickets for England.

Maddy Raman: Why do England insist on the conservative approach? All a nightwatchman does is lose momentum and cause wickets to tumble.

Fenners: Is it just me or does Buttler still have a lot to prove at international level?

Tony: Other people may see doom, I see opportunity. Few wickets yesterday, lots this morning; a good time for England to field.

Clearly it was my fault for suggesting earlier today that 500 was possible for England... James Anderson, playing his 100th Test, is the last man for the tourists - and their sixth left-hander in the XI. Roach angles one across him which Anderson slashes for four - every run is precious now.

Jonathan Agnew
BBC Test Match Special

"That really wasn't a very good shot. Stuart Broad can bat - he's got to just get over this issue with the short ball. He can't just roll over as easily as that."

Listen to TMS commentary via the audio icon (available in UK only).

Graeme Swann
Ex-England spinner on BBC Test Match Special

"I dare say Broad was expecting the short one. This England innings has absolutely fallen apart. The wicket of Ian Bell, although it wasn't celebrated with much verve and vigour last night, has given the West Indies a real fillip - they've been all over England this morning."

Stuart Broad is the third man to make a duck in this innings as he reaches for a wide ball - his third - and is pouched at backward point. England have lost four wickets for four runs, and the drinks break has struck.

Scorecard

Image source, Reuters

Sir Viv Richards
Ex-West Indies captain on BBC Test Match Special

Would you wear a helmet if you were a young player coming into the game today?

"Maybe because of the popularity of the helmet, I would have. But for me, the maroon cap was important."

You can send in your questions for Sir Viv for the lunchtime Q&A to @bbctms with the hashtag #askviv

England 357-7 (103 overs)

Batsmen: Jordan 4*, Broad 0*

Fall of wickets: 1-1 (Trott 0), 22-2 (Cook 11), 34-3 (Ballance 10), 211-4 (Root 83), 341-5 (Bell 143), 357-6 (Stokes 79), 357-7 (Tredwell 8), 361-8 (Buttler 0)

Bowling figures: Taylor 19-4-86-3, Roach 26-6-75-3, Holder 22-10-59-2, Benn 26-3-85-0, Samuels 10-0-46-0

West Indies won toss

Full scorecard

Kemar Roach, who has bowled five of the 13 overs so far this morning, has a little rest, sitting in the driver's seat of the drinks cart while the players rehydrate.

Sir Viv Richards
Ex-West Indies captain on BBC Test Match Special

"When you have a guy who is looking to get the other side of the ball, it does give the impression that the ticker isn't working that big. I'd be telling my bowlers to give Broad a few."

You can send in your questions for Sir Viv for the lunchtime Q&A to @bbctms with the hashtag #askviv

Stuart Broad is the new batsman, but for now he's the non-striker as the Holder v Jordan duel, made in Barbados, resumes. For now, Holder prevails as Jordan plays out a maiden - and the players have reached drinks.

Do you have a question for Sir Viv Richards? It's your lucky day - the great man will be answering the best of them on Test Match Special during the lunch interval at 17:00 BST.

Send your questions to tms@bbc.co.uk (with 'Ask Viv' in the subject line), tweet using #askviv, or text via 81111.

Sir Viv Richards
Ex-West Indies captain on BBC Test Match Special

"We spoke about the bowling coach Curtly Ambrose, and some of that passion has been exercised this morning. They've bowled with discipline, and this is a good comeback. It's West Indies's session so far. Buttler did contribute to that wicket - there was limited foot movement in trying to play that particular shot."

Listen to TMS commentary via the audio icon (available in UK only).

It's all over for Jos Buttler - who falls for an uncharacteristic 22-ball duck as he drives and edges to the keeper.

Buttler is a free-scoring one-day batsman whose ability to "get on with it" straight away caused many people to lament England's decision to send in a nightwatchman ahead of him last night. And as if to prove that hindsight is everything, he's been outscored by Tredwell.

Scorecard

Image source, Reuters

Paul: Shuddering at Sir Geoffrey's mention of Winston Benjamin. I played against him in Chester when he made his debut - clean bowled stumps flying everywhere. Benjamin took 100 league wickets that season.

A ring of cover fielders is keeping the squeeze on England - but finally Jordan takes England off the dreaded 357 as he forces a four through the covers. England's first run for 35 balls.

David Hill in Edinburgh: At the moment if England are faced with being bold or negative they will take the negative option, which explains Tredwell as the nightwatchman. They have to break out of this approach.

They have lost Stokes and Tredwell and the batting finishes after Jordan, Broad will be found at square leg and Jimmy can hardly get it off the square so Buttler may as well take it on, but will he be allowed to be bold? 400 in the first innings wins this match.

The third umpire has a look, and rules that there was an inside edge onto the pad - so Jordan survives.

Belatedly, the ball-tracker shows it was going over the stumps anyway.

Jordan hit on the knee-roll, West Indies appeal, umpire shakes head, Ramdin signals for a review...