Manchester

Welcome to Proper Manc

A bomb, gang turf wars and the rise of club culture - poet, author and broadcaster David Scott looks at Manchester in the 1990s

Watch & Listen

Latest Updates

  1. Will Amorim bring the glory days back?published at 18:46 1 November

    Media caption,

    Manchester United fans have 10 days to wait until Ruben Amorim takes charge at the club, following the announcement that he will be their new head coach.

    On the latest episode of The Football News Show, experts analyse what the Portuguese manager will change at United, how they will play under him and how successful he could be.

    Watch the show in full above or access it on iPlayer.

  2. 'Comes with credentials' but 'would not expect miracles' from Amorimpublished at 18:44 1 November

    Your views banner

    Earlier, we asked for your views on Ruben Amorim's appointment as head coach and what his first tasks will be at Manchester United.

    Here are some more of your comments:

    Liam: Comes with credentials and an impressive record over a short time. Would not expect miracles. Ten Hag bought some bad players. Rashford seems at times like he does not want to make the effort. Seems to be a problem with player power at Man Utd. If the players do not make the effort, the manager gets sacked. So the new man will have to sort this out first.

    Eldon: As a United fan all my life (50 years) I have seen managers come and go so we must be careful not to get carried away with the new man. He certainly plays the attacking football of old United so only time will tell if those glorious days and a fortress at the Theatre of Dreams can be reinstated.

    Philip: It's interesting that he is listed as being head coach and not manager with a contract only until 2027. Ineos seem to be playing it smart. It does show credit on his side that he wants some time to finish off with Sporting before he officially takes charge. United just need to start showing a reason for fans to believe.

  3. Walker pleased with Ballon d'Or 'recognition' for Rodripublished at 16:53 1 November

    You'll Never Beat Kyle Walker podcast promo banner

    Speaking on a new episode of You'll Never Beat Kyle Walker on BBC Sounds, the Manchester City captain paid tribute to City team-mate and Ballon d'Or winner Rodri.

    "For him, it's absolutely fantastic," said the England full-back. "I think he's been nothing short of probably perfect in the last couple of seasons. You can see what he means to Man City.

    "I think this season we've adapted very well without him but in the last couple of seasons when he's not really been there, we've not really been the same Man City. The goals that he's scored, the assists that he's provided, it's not really a defensive midfielder.

    "'Gundo' [Ilkay Gundogan] said something in a post someone sent me and for a defensive player to get that award, for us defensive-minded players it means a little bit more.

    "If you look at the last 10-15 years, you've got Messi and Ronaldo without a shadow of a doubt, then Luka's [Modric] got it and then Benzema. It's recognition for the work that he's putting in without getting the headlines."

    Listen to the full episode on BBC Sounds

    Listen on BBC Sounds banner
  4. Who is taking the bigger risk - Amorim or Man Utd?published at 16:25 1 November

    Media caption,

    Ruben Amorim was announced as the new head coach of Manchester United on Friday, beginning his role on Monday 11 November.

    The Sporting CP boss has turned their fortunes around in recent years and the reaction on Friday suggests United fans hope he can do the same at Old Trafford.

    But is it a big risk for the 39-year-old?

    Watch the latest Football News Show episode now

  5. 'A stellar appointment'published at 16:25 1 November

    Your views banner
    Old Trafford and Ruben AmorimImage source, Getty Images

    Earlier, we asked for your views on the appointment of Ruben Amorim as Manchester United head coach.

    Here are some of your comments:

    Matthew: For me, it seems players like the centre-backs, Ugarte and the physical Hojlund might benefit from this new potential back-three style. However, part of me fears for Bruno, or wingers like Rashford and Garnacho, as it seems they can't all be integrated into a 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 team, unless Fernandes drops deeper alongside Ugarte. But bring it on!

    Chris: A stellar appointment that was well overdue - great pedigree, football intellect and attractive football. This is the inspirational appointment we have been waiting on since Fergie departed.

    Mark: I am encouraged by the fact that he has taken an underperforming club and made them into serious winners. Sir Alex Ferguson did something similar with Aberdeen. His man-management and coaching skills will be tested. I wish him well.

    An image detailing how to follow your Premier League team on BBC Sport: "On the app? Tap the bell icon to get news about your club sent to you. Signed in on a browser? Hit 'Follow' to stay up to date.
  6. 'Amorim comes in with a good pedigree'published at 16:25 1 November

    Ruben AmorimImage source, Getty Images

    Former Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert, speaking on BBC Radio 5 Live about Ruben Amorim becoming Manchester United head coach: "It is a great club and a great job for him to have a good run at it. Maybe he is the right man but time will tell.

    "He comes in with a good pedigree and it is a different type of football. It is different to when Jose Mourinho came over and he became that great manager after success in Europe.

    "This is a little bit different. The great thing is he has a great club and fanbase behind him. Hopefully he is a big success because I think everyone needs to see Manchester United up there.

    "If he can get a tune out of the players then he will do really well."

    Follow live updates on Amorim's appointment and the rest of Friday's football news

  7. 🎧 What a week!published at 16:24 1 November

    The Devils' Advocate podcast graphic

    As Ruben Amorim's appointment was confirmed, The Devils' Advocate team moved to release a bonus podcast.

    You can listen to the episode here

    Listen on BBC Sounds banner
  8. Guardiola wrestles with injury issuespublished at 15:49 1 November

    Simon Stone
    Chief football news reporter

    Manchester City expert view banner

    As soon as Pep Guardiola answered my opening question at Friday's press conference with "you'll see tomorrow", I got the sense the Manchester City boss was not going to be too forthcoming about his side's injury issues.

    Part of it will be to keep Bournemouth manager Andoni Iraola guessing over who will be in the City side at Vitality Stadium, but part will also be because he is waiting to discover exactly who is available and for how long.

    Guardiola accepted it is not unusual for clubs to suffer a long injury list. He also knows what a negative impact it can have.

    He mentioned Liverpool. In 2022-23 Jurgen Klopp's men in the end did well to finish fifth, with 67 points, a year after they had finished second with 92.

    That is the scenario Guardiola will be anxious to avoid this season.

    City are top. But you get the sense if they win a fifth Premier League title in a row, he would regard this one as the best.

  9. 'Coach' Amorim, not 'manager'published at 14:49 1 November

    Simon Stone
    Chief football news reporter

    Manchester United expert view banner

    A couple of things stood out in the statements from Manchester United and Sporting about Ruben Amorim's move to Old Trafford.

    Firstly, United named Amorim as "head coach". Just over two years ago, Erik ten Hag came in as manager.

    That suggests Amorim will not have the same input on the recruitment side as Ten Hag had - which many might think is not a bad thing.

    The other is Sporting confirming United have paid an additional 1m euros to bring in Amorim before the end of the 30-day notice period he was supposed to serve.

    United are clearly keen to get their man during the international break. It is expected his coaches will be on board by then too.

    What that means for Ruud van Nistelrooy is open to question. The Dutchman made a point yesterday of confirming his intention to return to the assistant manager's role and that he had 18 months left on his contract.

    United will have to pay their former striker to leave.

  10. Is Amorim the right man?published at 14:49 1 November

    Media caption,

    Manchester United fans can contemplate a new beginning.

    So how are they feeling about Ruben Amorim? The Football News Show found out.

    Watch the show

    An image detailing how to follow your Premier League team on BBC Sport: "On the app? Tap the bell icon to get news about your club sent to you. Signed in on a browser? Hit 'Follow' to stay up to date.
  11. Guardiola on Savinho and 'not feeling sorry for themselves'published at 14:26 1 November

    Katie Stafford
    BBC Sport journalist

    Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola has been speaking to the media before Saturday's Premier League game against Bournemouth (kick-off 15:00 GMT).

    Here are the key lines from his news conference:

    • Savinho could be available for Saturday's trip to Vitality Stadium as it was "just a strong knock" he suffered against Tottenham and "no fracture".

    • Guardiola says he "has many doubts" about who else could recover in time and he will "talk to players and the doctors" on Saturday morning.

    • He said "we are in an emergency in certain positions" but the academy players are there to support and he trusts them.

    • More on City's growing injury list: "It is what it is. It happens in many clubs and we're not the only club in the world to be going through it."

    • Guardiola said he has told the players to "not feel sorry for ourselves".

    • He said "the squad is enough when completely focused and fit" in response to whether he will look to bring players in during the January transfer window.

    • On whether a conversation needs to be had about the football calendar and its toll on players' health: "We know it [is too many games], but it is the reality. We try to take care of them. We’ve not done anything differently to previous seasons. If anything we’ve trained less. But it happens and you have to adapt."

    Follow all of Friday's Premier League news conferences and the rest of the day's football news

    An image detailing how to follow your Premier League team on BBC Sport: "On the app? Tap the bell icon to get news about your club sent to you. Signed in on a browser? Hit 'Follow' to stay up to date.
  12. Man Utd 'need someone with character and charisma' - Ferdinandpublished at 13:03 1 November

    Ruben Amorim gestures from the touchlineImage source, Getty Images

    Manchester United legend Rio Ferdinand believes new head coach Ruben Amorim has the pedigree and charisma to succeed at Old Trafford.

    Speaking on his YouTube channel, Rio Ferdinand Presents, the former United defender explained what separates Amorim from his predecessor Erik ten Hag.

    "If Pep Guardiola had gone, I think that Amorim would have been someone that City were looking at," said ex-England centre-back Ferdinand.

    "There are similarities to what Erik ten Hag was doing at Ajax but what I would say is that Amorim took a club that was on a barren spell.

    "They couldn't compete with Porto or Benfica, hadn't got near to winning the league. Disenchanted fanbase. Turmoil behind the scenes. He went in there and immediately turned their fortunes around. He changed their style of football, style of play, and expectations.

    "I think the biggest difference between the two (Amorim and Ten Hag), from what I am hearing from people who have played for but also been around, is the character and charisma compared to Erik ten Hag will be the big difference.

    "United need someone with the character and charisma to go 'you know what, I don't care what has happened here, I see a player in you, I see a player in you.' You need someone who is going to be like that.

    "This is a man who built Manuel Ugarte, who has come to Manchester United. He built a £60m player. He changed the landscape for a football club. That is not easy to do. I don't care what league you are in.

    "I spoke to [former United team-mate] Nani the other day and he said 'Rio, the players love him, the players play for him, love him and they respect him'.

    "He said Amorim is very straight and direct. Maybe there were inconsistencies in the way Ten Hag disciplined. You have to have clear lines when you approach these topics and players."

    Have your say on Amorim's appointment, external

  13. 'A very complex dressing room at Manchester United'published at 12:52 1 November

    Ruben Amorim looks on from benchImage source, Getty Images

    United We Stand editor and writer for The Athletic, Andy Mitten, speaking to BBC Radio 5 Live: "I'm sure he will get a honeymoon period like the last six or seven United managers in the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era.

    "He is very highly rated, like the last managers have been too. He has a very difficult job, a very complex dressing room at Manchester United. The team has underwhelmed.

    "[The dressing room is] complex because their ability is not to the same standard as their rivals. The remuneration might be, their social media followings might be, but how many of those Manchester united players might get into a top rival team.

    "Confidence is low. They have been starting games playing well but unable to follow through with the manager's instructions. There are some big egos in there from all around the world.

    "It is difficult for a manager to go in and wrestle with a team that is underperforming. It is much easier to go into a dressing room that is confident and winning.

    "I wish the new manager well. I hope he can do the same job as at Sporting when he found them in a perilous state. But it is about more than just the football at Manchester United.

    "The pressures are huge. You are going to get abuse from all around the world every single time you lose a match, the players will as well. Expectations are high because it is such a huge football club, it is Manchester United and there is a lot of pressure that comes with that."