Summary

  • TB case confirmed at Dudley hospital

  • Ex-BBC host found woodland sex 'erotic'

  • Bus lane camera catches more than 20,000 drivers

  • Electrocuted teen has 'life-changing' injuries

  • Six arrested after fight at fast food restaurant

  • Woakes injury rules him out of England duty

  • Updates from Friday 2 June 2017

  1. Victims 'listening intently'published at 12:01 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    The judge is reading out what happened to John Ingram (pictured), Carole Johnson and Leanne Joseph.

    Victim John IngramImage source, PA

    All are sat staring at the man who mutilated them.

  2. Judge goes over victim statementspublished at 11:52 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    The judge is continuing to go over the victim statements, he is talking about the Marian Moran case in 1998.

    Paterson carried out further unnecessary procedures and surgery over the next few years, culminating in a mastectomy which wasn't needed.

    Judith Conduit is staring at Paterson, he’s looking down.

    The judge cites another unnecessary operation.

    Patricia Welch, another victim, is sat next to Ms Conduit and is also staring at Paterson.

  3. Victim 'staring intently at Paterson'published at 11:44 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Ian Paterson continues to shakes his head as Mr Justice Jeremy Baker goes through the victim statements.

    John Ingram is sitting the closest of all the victims in court, he is staring intently at Paterson.

  4. 'Exaggerated risks'published at 11:42 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    "You deliberately exaggerated the risk that patients would develop cancer," the judge tells Paterson.

    "The reality was there was little if any need for continued surveillance or the surgery or procedures."

    Ian PatersonImage source, PA
  5. 'They relied on you'published at 11:40 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Mr Justice Jeremy Baker is talking about Paterson's past.

    "You began to undertake private as well as NHS work.

    "By 37 you had a thriving private practice specialising in breast problems, regarded by local GPs as the go-to specialist to which they'd refer their patients.

    "Private patients either paid via insurance or their own pockets.

    "They all thought they had breast cancer and relied on you."

  6. 'You carried out surgery which you knew was unnecessary'published at 11:38 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Mr Justice Jeremy Baker is now going through the counts and the offending period number of victims.

    "You carried out surgery which you knew was unnecessary."

    Paterson is shaking his head.

    "You qualified as a doctor in your 20s, became a surgeon aged 35."

  7. Judge back in courtpublished at 11:35 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Mr Justice Jeremy Baker is back in court and ready to deliver his verdict.

  8. 'I've lost my home and my job because of him. Now I want to see him suffer'published at 11:26 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Rebecca Woods
    BBC News Online, Journalist

    Several victims spoke to the BBC about the treatment they received from Ian Paterson.

    Frances Perks lost her mother and sister to breast cancer, so when a lump showed up on a mammogram when she was 35, she was referred to Paterson. During one consultation, he urged her to have a double mastectomy or risk "full-blown cancer".

    Frances PerksImage source, Gavin Dickson

    She had her left breast removed and underwent eight other operations at the private Spire Parkway Hospital in Solihull, West Midlands.

    However, she later learned that none had been necessary.

    The effect on her life has been devastating. She had to give up her job because of the stress, leading to her losing her home.

  9. Defence gives mitigation in less than five minutespublished at 11:17 British Summer Time 31 May 2017
    Breaking

    Defending, Nicholas Johnson, says he agrees with the parameters as set out by prosecution.

    There is no pre-sentence report, his evidence has been heard, he adds.

    The judge, Mr Justice Jeremy Baker, says he will rise before sentencing.

    His decision is due at 11.30.

  10. Court told to consider compensation orderpublished at 11:12 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    The prosecution says the court needs to consider compensation to the victims, but that's in straightforward cases and this isn't.

    Paterson has benefited financially, so there’s scope for confiscation proceedings under the 1988 act.

    Paterson is paying close attention to these details.

    However, there are civil proceedings seeking compensation and costs shouldn't be made because it will deplete the assets available for compensation.

  11. Potential life sentence for surgeonpublished at 11:04 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Wounding with intent carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, while unlawful wounding is five years in prison.

    Paterson has been found guilty of 17 counts of wounding with intent and three counts of unlawful wounding.

    The prosecution say he's not a continuing danger to the public.

  12. Ian Paterson 'is a monster'published at 11:02 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Another statement is read out, this time from Carole Johnson who isn't here.

    She said she feels guilt because she recommended Ian Paterson to her daughter.

    "I feel violated and vulnerable and have lost confidence.

    "The fact he denied it and put me on the witness stand made it even harder.

    "He is a monster," her statement added.

  13. Victim's husband holds hand as statement read outpublished at 11:00 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Another of Paterson's patients, Patricia Welch, looks visibly upset in court.

    Llike the others, her statement explains how it’s affected her as well as her husband and children.

    Her husband is holding her hand.

    She is self conscious about scarring, her statement adds.

    "I initially came to terms thinking my life had been saved.

    "Now when I look in the mirror I see a victim of Mr Paterson who took away part of me as a woman."

  14. 'I feel real hatred'published at 10:59 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Victim Judith Conduit is staring at Paterson from her seat.

    Her victim impact describes the physical and psychological scars.

    “I will never understand or be able to forgive him… I feel real hatred for what he has done,” her statement adds.

  15. 'I will never be free of the effects'published at 10:57 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    The prosecution is reading out a victim statement from Rosemary Platt who isn't in court today.

    She had to have more procedures as a result of the surgery carried out by Paterson and also suffered anxiety and depression.

    Ian PatersonImage source, Other
    Image caption,

    Ian Paterson during a breast cancer charity ball in 2009

    Her trust in medical professionals has been shaken and she is still anxious about having to give more evidence in the GMC and civil cases.

    "I will never be free of the effects of these unnecessary operations."

  16. 'I've tried to move on'published at 10:52 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    John Ingram has finished reading the court his impact statement, by saying he tried to move on and "has trained to be a counsellor".

    Mr Ingram added: "It is a source of great comfort that the trial ends today."

  17. 'It is truly chilling cruel behaviour, it is beyond dark'published at 10:51 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    "He knew he was doing a completely unnecessary operation, but still carried on," Mr Ingram continued.

    "It is truly chilling, cruel behaviour: it is beyond dark."

    Paterson keeps shaking his head whilst John Ingram gives his impact statement.

    "His lack of remorse is passive perpetuation of the insult we suffer."

    Ian PatersonImage source, Press Association
  18. 'Paterson deceived and manipulated me'published at 10:47 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Mr Ingram is telling the court of the physical effects of Ian Paterson's treatment. His loss of nipples and continued pain.

    "Psychologically I was positive after the surgery because he told me he’d saved me from breast cancer, and thought I was cured.

    "During the recall I was told the surgery had been unnecessary, initially thought it was just a difference of opinion, but then it became clear Paterson had deceived and manipulated me."

    Paterson shakes his head.

    "I needed two years of further treatment. I was a lot sicker than I needed to be for a lot longer because of Paterson."

    Paterson has his head bowed.

  19. Victim John Ingram: 'He has shown no remorse'published at 10:44 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    "Ian Paterson is a criminal," Mr Ingram told the packed courtroom.

    John Ingram

    "He won't accept the statement, but I’ll say it again, he is a criminal.

    "He committed grotesque violent acts against me. He has shown no remorse.

    "The effects have been physical and mental. He removed healthy tissue from my chest for no reason."

  20. First victim stands to read victim impact statementpublished at 10:42 British Summer Time 31 May 2017

    Phil Mackie
    Midlands correspondent, BBC News

    Ian Paterson is in the dock for the first time, Julian Christopher QC is prosecuting.

    Seven of the victims have prepared victim impact statements.

    Mr Ingram, Paterson's only male victim in the court case, stands with applause from the public gallery.

    The Judge asks for quiet.