'I’d love replays to be re-instated'published at 15:57 Greenwich Mean Time
Phil McNulty Q&A
Phil McNulty
BBC Sport chief football writer
Sam from Bournemouth: Good Morning Phil, FA Cup Replays Is the Magic here Fading Amidst Continental and intercontinental football Clashes for our “top” teams?
With top Premier League teams juggling intercontinental competitions, FA Cup replays seem to have lost their charm but more generally I think this has been happening to our domestic cups for a while.
The suggestion in the modern era that the cups mean as much as the league seems ludicrous! In Germany, a smaller league arguably strikes a better balance. Is it time for English football to consider a leaner top division with just 18 teams to reignite cup interest and possibly even replays?
Morning, Sam. I don’t think the FA Cup has lost its magic, but it has certainly lost something with the removal of replays. My view is that this was a decision that pandered to the so-called “bigger” clubs following their complaints about fixture congestion, and it is a real shame.
I’d love replays to be re-instated – but do not think we will be getting a leaner Premier League.