Summary

  1. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 09:55 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Just copy ice hockey and draw two actual lines across the pitch dividing it into thirds. Can’t enter the final third until the ball is played. Done.

    J

    Not sure about getting rid of offside, however it isn't in small sided and, in my experience, doesn't usually be lead to goal hanging as teams need to defend too! Offside should be given as soon as it happens if it is blatantly obvious. There has to be a clear mandate for offside. The question should be how much of an advantage does your little toes give you? Let semi automatic draw the lines quickly but let a human realistically decide if there is any advantage gained from an arm being in advance.

    Michael in Lincolnshire

    In Hockey we had offside from the half way line changed to a 25yrd line then eventually no offsides at all. It greatly improved the spectacle and speed of the game. I am not saying it is the same but I would be all for moving the offside line from the halfway to a 25yrd line as it will make the pitch bigger and create more opportunities to score!

    Sharkyward

  2. Celtic transfer window 'not ideal' concedes Rodgerspublished at 09:52 Greenwich Mean Time

    Brendan RogersImage source, Getty Images

    News from the Scottish Premiership.

    Yesterday, manager Brendan Rodgers admitted the January transfer window "wasn't ideal" for Celtic but is not apportioning blame ahead of a club review.

    The Scottish Premiership leaders signed Jeffrey Schlupp from Crystal Palace on deadline day and brought winger Jota back from Rennes, with forward Kyogo Furuhashi moving in the opposite direction.

    "I said it myself, we wanted another striker, so we're not hiding behind anything," said Rodgers.

    "And absolutely, the supporters will look and see that a top striker has gone out, a legendary striker.

    "So I understand that. But all I can do is affect what we have now and look to teach and work very hard and finish off what has been, until now, a great season for us."

  3. Postpublished at 09:50 Greenwich Mean Time

    Yep, understood. I didn't really think it through.

  4. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 09:45 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Re doing away with the offside rule: You'd end up with attackers lurking in the goalmouth trying to irritate goalkeepers, with the opposition hoofing it towards goal. Not pretty.

    Lyndon, New Forest

  5. Postpublished at 09:38 Greenwich Mean Time

    And that's all from Liverpool's news conference. Many thanks to Arne Slot for distracting us from my terrible scrap offsides suggestion.

    Not my finest ratio.

    We'll be chatting more about Liverpool and the rest of the EFL Cup semi-finalists a little later.

    86 thumbs up and 368 thumbs down
  6. 'I don't understand why we cannot name 23 players in this country'published at 09:34 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool v Tottenham (Thu, 20:00 GMT)

    Liverpool

    Liverpool manager Arne Slot delivered a long answer when asked how he keeps all the players in his squad happy now that he has a near fully fit group to choose from: "That is one of the only things that I don't understand here in England. Everywhere around the world and in Europe as well when we play Champions League, we can take 23 players to the game. We are here in a country where we play the most games - especially the ones like us, Arsenal, Aston Villa, Chelsea - all the ones that are playing in Europe.

    "We play so, so many games. If you are able to play all of these games, you need a big squad, that seems to be fair to me. One of the things that is so important for a manager - to pick the first 11 is difficult - but to tell someone they aren't even in the squad makes it even harder. I don't understand why we don't go to 23 in this country because this country plays the most games out of anywhere in the world and we only have 20 players we can take to the game. It's not for that game because nine substitute is more than enough but it would keep the dressing room going.

    "You need more than 20 players in this country because we play so many games. Why can't we bring 23 players to the game instead of 20? That will be the most difficult decision I have to make tomorrow - to leave someone out who works so hard on a daily basis and wants to be involved - that is the hardest decision for me to make."

  7. Slot remains tight-lipped on goalkeeper choicepublished at 09:27 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool v Tottenham (Thu, 20:00 GMT)

    Liverpool

    Liverpool manager Arne Slot on who will get the nod out of Alisson Becker and Caoimhin Kelleher for tomorrow evening's game: "The two goalkeepers don't know yet. When I leave this room, I am going to go to the media next door and then afterwards I will inform the goalkeepers which decision I have made."

  8. 'It may add even more pressure on referees'published at 09:22 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool v Tottenham (Thu, 20:00 GMT)

    Liverpool

    Liverpool manager Arne Slot on referees potentially announcing key decisions to the crowd from the start of next season: "For me, it is not necessary because I can go two steps backwards and see the live coverage of anything but that isn't available to fans so if the fans like this then let's do this. If the fans like it then let's continue but let's see if they do because the last time it happened I was there in the Spurs stadium and it was so obvious - it was not necessary to announce it was offside.

    "I think the one we were interested in is why he didn't give the second yellow card [to Lucas Bergvall] and that is something he didn't have to explain. I think maybe if he does explain it and it's a disadvantage for the home team then it becomes even more of a pressure on the referee so I wonder if it is a good thing for the referee. It will add more pressure on the next and the next and the next decision. "

  9. 'We are happy with the team that we have'published at 09:15 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool v Tottenham (Thu, 20:00 GMT)

    Liverpool

    Liverpool manager Arne Slot on whether he was satisfied with the January transfer window: "I've said it many times, we have a very good squad and if you look at the league table, the players have shown that the trust we have in them was correct. We don't have, apart from Trent now, many long-term injuries.

    "We did have some injury problems with Alisson and Diogo Jota and some others but at the moment, apart from Trent, they were all available today. So, there is not a reason to add something to the team unless you have a chance in the market. That is something we saw last time with the goalkeeper [Giorgi Mamardashvili] we brought in because we saw there was a chance in the market. For now, we are happy with the team that we have."

  10. Alexander-Arnold to miss Spurs match through injurypublished at 09:11 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool v Tottenham (Thu, 20:00 GMT)

    Liverpool

    Liverpool manager Arne Slot on Trent Alexander-Arnold's injury: "He is going to miss the game tomorrow. We will have to see if he can play Sunday but what we do know is that he is not available for tomorrow.

    "He left the pitch with a bit of a pain in his leg [against Bournemouth]. He is already back on the pitch with the rehab coach so let's see how long it is going to take but he will not be available for tomorrow."

  11. Postpublished at 09:09 Greenwich Mean Time

    Liverpool

    Hang on, Arne Slot's just sat down and is about to talk to the media.

  12. Postpublished at 09:07 Greenwich Mean Time

    Genuine question, and I absolutely promise I'm not just saying this for clicks, should we just do away with the offside rule?

  13. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 09:05 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    James, Cardiff:RE Alan at 08:37 Going back to daylight will result in the same uncertainty around whether or not there is daylight - you’ll still need to draw lines to determine any overlap. What we need is a “too close to call” system where if the offside is less than 5 cm or so, the benefit of the doubt goes to the attacker.

    Joe, Manchester: RE Alan 08:37 - how does clear daylight make it any easier? If anything it's worse because then you have to determine whether there is the overlapping of an attackers heel and a defenders toe preventing daylight.

    Matt, Scotland: Reply to Alan 08:37. People talk about 'going back to daylight between defender and striker' as if it would solve all the problems, but to see daylight it would still need someone to either draw a line on a screen, or for the linesman to make an on field decision at the time of a pass. Either option leaves us in same position as we are now, so people would still moan.

  14. Irish teenager Melia in 'record' transfer to Spurspublished at 09:02 Greenwich Mean Time

    Mason Melia in actionImage source, Getty Images

    Missed this one? Last night, teenager Mason Melia agreed to join Tottenham Hotspur for what St Patrick's Athletic have announced is a "record transfer fee for a League of Ireland player".

    The 17-year-old made his senior debut in May 2023 and became the youngest scorer in league history aged 15.

    The deal, which is reportedly worth an initial £1.6m, will see Melia move from St Pat's to the Premier League side in January 2026 on a five-year contract.

    The County Wicklow native has made 54 appearances for St Pat's, scoring 10 times, and earned his first call-up to the Republic of Ireland Under-21 squad in October 2024.

    In 2023, he became the youngest player to play in an FAI Cup final when he helped his side defeat Bohemians to lift the trophy.

  15. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 08:57 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only, standard rates apply)

    James, Cornwall: Agree with Alan at 08:37. Similar to the whole of the ball being completely over the line, the significant body parts of head and feet need to be distinctly in front of the defender to signify an unfair advantage. Rather than just possible signs of the attacker moving quicker than the defender.

    Mark, Hastings: Totally agree with Alan at 08:37 - anyone remember Bamford's goal being ruled out because his hand was offside? You cannot score a goal with your hand.

  16. get involved

    Get Involved - Favourite veteran footballerspublished at 08:53 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Kenny DalglishImage source, Getty Images

    Not the oldest on this list, but Kenny Dalglish was still playing for Liverpool at 39. Puts the Mo Salah contract situation into perspective - give him what he wants!

    Christian, Liverpool

  17. Postpublished at 08:49 Greenwich Mean Time

    Some housekeeping. At about 09:00 GMT Liverpool we'll have a manager's news conference.

    Liverpool play Tottenham on Thursday. We'll have the best of Arne Slot's quotes.

  18. Postpublished at 08:47 Greenwich Mean Time

    We could have a VARSTED inspection where a former official sits in a corner at Stockley Park with a clipboard.

  19. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 08:42 Greenwich Mean Time

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Who is appraising VAR? Maybe we need an OFSTED for VAR. 4 errors is laughable.

    Dan, London

  20. Postpublished at 08:40 Greenwich Mean Time

    Thanks for messaging Alan, sounds very similar to something Arsene Wenger suggested a few years ago.