Stuart Broad is ominously surrounded at the crease, like a lone scuba diver encircled by menacing black fins. Craig entices the feeding frenzy with an absolute gem of a first delivery, zipping one out of the footholes, but his next delivery releases the pressure and is sliced away to the cover boundary by Broad.

billybunter3rd: Oh dear Moeen. Didn't know where off stump was when bowling and still doesn't know when batting! #eyestested

Chris Hall: Not sure Moeen's three runs and 1-121 are good enough with bat or ball. Either let Root bowl spin part-time or pick a proper spinner.

Image source, Getty Images

A hostile over from Henry ends as Buttler plays and misses outside off stump.

Charlie: A friend emailed me a few hours ago with the below text. "I'm sat on a Leeds to Southampton flight and believe it or not, the captain has just announced 'unfortunately the wind means today's flight will be somewhere between lumpy and ropey'."

Broad guides a single through the leg side, and when Henry aims a yorker, Buttler fluently turns it off his toes for four past the square leg umpire. Henry has his revenge as Buttler is smacked on his top (left) hand by a lifter, immediately walking away in agony as the England physio runs on to have a look and apply the magic spray. Not what you want to see happening to the digits of your first-choice wicketkeeper.

Image source, Reuters

Madeleine: Memo to Root - Enthusiasm and positive thinking: great. Making us look like chumps: not so great.

Simon Mann
BBC Test Match Special

"In a way, Broad is England's Tim Southee. He doesn't block, he's not an ideal player to come in when you've got a situation like this."

Image source, AFP

It's all about survival now, even for the previously positive Buttler. He blocks and leaves his way through a third successive maiden for Mark Craig.

Steven F. Galloway: I've gone from thoughts of an England win, to hoping for a draw, to just wanting there to be some cricket on when I finish work.

Stuart Broad is the new man and he's lucky to survive the rest of Craig's over, playing an eyes-closed fend to an absolute snorter and seeing the ball loop kindly over the slips.

Graeme Swann
Ex-England spinner on BBC Test Match Special

"There's two types of leave in cricket - and this was a pretty terrible bad one. Moeen Ali wasn't looking to score, and that's his downfall. It didn't just flick the bail, it absolutely crunched into off stump."

Image source, Getty Images

What a way to go when you're trying to save a Test match. Moeen shoulders arms to an angled-in delivery from Henry and watches on in horror as it splatters his off pole. No, no, no. England staring down the barrel.

Image source, Getty Images

Graeme Swann
Ex-England spinner on BBC Test Match Special

"England have been the architects of their own downfall. Joe Root can consider himself unlucky, but Ian Bell's was a poor dismissal after leg slip had been brought in, you don't hit it there. Mark Craig bowled so many bad balls in his first spell that England had the chance to hit him out of the attack, but they blocked and left it, and allowed him to settle. If they had hit out, he wouldn't have had a short leg, silly point and leg slip to a new batsman."

Craig continues, his floppy fringe flapping in the breeze like the long grass on a seaside links. Buttler plays out a maiden.

Peter Ganney: Listening to @bbctms live 38,000 feet over the Atlantic. This is what satellite internet was made for.

You can listen to the TMS journalists' panel debate from lunchtime on the TMS podcast page.

Is this partnership England's last hope? The sun is shining, the weather is sweet and New Zealand are one wicket away from the tail. Moeen gets off the mark after ten scoreless deliveries with a back-foot off-side push off Henry.

Jonathan Agnew
BBC Test Match Special

"Given the two umpire's call flags, I'm surprised it took so long for Cook to review that decision. But New Zealand are four wickets from a famous win."

Evan Samuel: Talk about the kiss of death.. oh no, Chef! Had to review. Close, but that's it really.

Chris Bloomfield: And that is goodnight England.

Steady, Moeen, steady - his eyes light up at a wide one from Craig but is lucky not to snick it out of the footholes. Maiden from Craig.

What an inspired change that was from Brendon McCullum - bringing on the part-time tweaker and snaring the England kingpin. Williamson continues his record of phenomenal, freakish success against England. Buttler angles a Henry delivery down to the third man boundary with new man Moeen waiting at the non-striker's end.