John Southall
BBC Radio 5 live football reporter in Valencia

Image source, Getty Images

United played well in the last 10 minutes of the game when they created chances and could have got it back to 2-2.

They improved but Juan Mata just couldn't get a decent touch on the ball in the 90th minute. But on their overall performance they didn't deserve to get a point.

Phil Jones' own-goal was shambolic. There is no hiding it.

Lyon are into the Champions League knockout stages after finishing the group unbeaten.

After beating Manchester City in the opening game, they drew their next five - including this 1-1 draw at Shakhtar Donetsk - to move into the last 16.

Juventus suffered their second defeat of the season, losing 2-1 to Young Boys, but still top the group thanks to Manchester United's loss.

Pat Nevin
Former Scotland winger on BBC Radio 5 live

Phil Foden played well but he didn't stand out. I have seen him play better than that, and he will have to play better than that if he wants to push into the team on a regular basis when everyone is fit.

Image source, Getty Images

Andy West
Spanish football writer

This group stage has been a great argument for drastically restructuring the Champions League. There have been some great games and some upsets, but the 16 teams advancing into the knockouts are exactly the 16 teams everyone would have expected.

Pat Nevin
Former Scotland winger on BBC Radio 5 live

City had a chance where they had three attackers on one defender and Hoffenheim were doing it with 25 minutes to go.

It's naive but it heartens you that they will give everything to win. Had David Silva or Kevin de Bruyne been playing tonight it would have been more than 2-1.

It's all over in Amsterdam, Bayern Munich win Group E with a 3-3 draw away to Ajax.

AEK Athens finish on zero points after Alex Grimaldo's late winner for Benfica.

Group runners-up:

Atletico Madrid

Tottenham

Liverpool

Schalke

Ajax

Lyon

Roma

Manchester United

Group winners:

Borussia Dortmund

Barcelona

PSG

Porto

Bayern Munich

Manchester City

Real Madrid

Juventus

Bonkers game. Absolutely nuts.

Image source, Reuters

Stephen: I always want United to lose, but it would really be handy tonight. City's second round options already don't look great. Let's not add Juventus to the mix.

It's 3-3 in Ajax v Bayern Munich now with Niklas Sule scoring an own goal - the Dutch side have two minutes left to find a winner to top the group.

Gary Flintoff
BBC Radio 5 live reporter at Etihad Stadium

The Hoffenheim fans have been fantastic this evening. They have just gone crazy, dancing up and down behind Ederson’s goal. They have certainly enjoyed themselves tonight, despite the result.

Pat Nevin
Former Scotland winger on BBC Radio 5 live

If there is any weakness generally at Manchester City, it is at left back. Fabian Delph often gets his angles wrong and people can drift past him.

And a late chance for United! Fine play from Paul Pogba too, the wedge pass over the top catches Valencia square, Juan Mata is in behind and has a swing at it - but it's a swing and a miss. No connection...

Image source, Getty Images

Lewis: If Phil Jones and Theresa May still have their jobs tomorrow morning, the world has gone mad.

Phil: This performance and result should surprise no one - United at full strength in competitive games slog through 90 mins let alone a dead rubber with a second string side

Fine play from Reiss Nelson! He gallops clear of Fabian Delph, looks for a team-mate in the middle and his cutback is charged down by Aymeric Laporte.

Kingsley Coman has now put Bayern Munich 3-2 up against Ajax. Thriller.