1. HALF-TIMEpublished at 20:52 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Atletico Madrid 0-0 Juventus

    Rodrigo Bentancur and Diego CostaImage source, Reuters
  2. HALF-TIMEpublished at 20:51 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    Manchester CityImage source, Reuters

    The most VAR half in Champions League history?

  3. Postpublished at 20:50 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    Danny Mills
    Former Man City defender on BBC Radio 5 live

    It's an unbelievable turn of events. City were leading, comfortable and dominating possession, with almost 70%. They were cruising.

    But the handball, which is the massive turning point because it changes the whole atmosphere and the way the game flows, I'm still not convinced about.

  4. Keep it tight!published at 45+3 mins

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    Manchester City have conceded at least two goals in six of their last seven Champions League knock-out ties.

    They have had 67% of the ball and had 10 shots on goal to Schalke's four. There's number 11, Bernardo Silva curling over from 20 yards.

  5. Postpublished at 45+2 mins

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    John Murray is currently reading out the laws of handball. Tells you that it's been a controversial first half...

  6. Postpublished at 20:48 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    Danny Mills
    Former Man City defender on BBC Radio 5 live

    Fernandinho is touching his waist. That's not a foul. But maybe because of that their legs get tangled.

    It's not deliberate but he prevents Salif Sane getting towards the ball. I can understand why that one was given.

    FernandinhoImage source, Reuters
  7. INJURY TIMEpublished at 45+1 mins

    Schalke 2-1 Manchester City

    Five minutes added on - it's all happened in Gelsenkirchen...

  8. goal

    GOAL - Schalke 2-1 Manchester Citypublished at 45 mins

    Nabil Bentaleb (Pen)

    Who saw this coming?! Not me!

    Nabil Bentaleb goes the other way, firing to Ederson's right, and while the keeper gets a hand to it he can't keep it out.

    Nabil BentalebImage source, Reuters
  9. YELLOW CARD - Fernandinho bannedpublished at 20:45 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 1-1 Manchester City

    And Fernandinho is banned now for the second leg!

  10. PENALTY TO SCHALKE!published at 43 mins

    Schalke 1-1 Manchester City

    Another one!

    Schalke have a free-kick, referee Carlos del Cerro Grande gives a pen instantly! Fernandinho had his hands on the hips of Salif Sane and the ref was in no doubt...

  11. YELLOW CARD - Otamendi bannedpublished at 42 mins

    Schalke 1-1 Manchester City

    Just to really annoy Manchester City, that booking shown to Nicolas Otamendi for the handball means he is suspended for the second leg.

  12. Postpublished at 20:41 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    John Murray
    BBC football correspondent

    So much for the chat that VAR would get rid of controversies...

    Nicolas OtamendiImage source, Reuters
  13. Postpublished at 20:40 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 1-1 Manchester City

    Danny Mills
    Former Man City defender on BBC Radio 5 live

    I don't know what is handball and what isn't anymore. Otamendi is trying to get his arm out of the way, it's in a natural position, but it stops the ball hitting the target.

  14. Postpublished at 39 mins

    Schalke 1-1 Manchester City

    The VAR controversy will rumble on and on, and there's another chapter. Whether it was a penalty or not it's got to be quicker than that, I reckon.

    Took an age.

    VARImage source, Getty Images
  15. goal

    GOAL - Schalke 1-1 Manchester Citypublished at 38 mins

    Nabil Bentaleb (Pen)

    That took an awfully long time but Schalke are level as former Spurs midfielder Nabil Bentaleb sends Ederson the wrong way to bury from the spot.

    Nabil BentalebImage source, Reuters
  16. Postpublished at 20:38 Greenwich Mean Time 20 February 2019

    Schalke 0-1 Manchester City

    Danny Mills
    Former Man City defender on BBC Radio 5 live

    If it was on the goal-line what would you say? A penalty and a red card.

  17. PENALTY TO SCHALKE!published at 36 mins

    Schalke 0-1 Manchester City

    A long, long delay but now they have decided that is a penalty!

    Otamendi is booked too.

  18. VAR

    Video Assistant Refereepublished at 34 mins

    Schalke 0-1 Manchester City

    Referee Carlos del Cerro Grande is talking to the VAR...

    He's now called the captains over to tell them to tell their players not to crowd around him. This is a massive stoppage.

    Carlos del Cerro GrandeImage source, Reuters
  19. PENALTY APPEALpublished at 33 mins

    Schalke 0-1 Manchester City

    Here come Schalke, Daniel Caligiuri moves on to his left foot and has a shot, deflected away for a corner.

    Schalke want a penalty! They think it was blocked by Nicolas Otamendi's arm...

  20. Postpublished at 32 mins

    Schalke 0-1 Manchester City

    Schalke did finish second in the Bundesliga last season but they look average at best, I'd have to agree. Not sure you can have a dig at any one side for being lucky when it comes to cup draws though!

    City have a free-kick in a dangerous spot, Kevin de Bruyne lines it up - he curls one in and Ralf Fahrman makes a regulation stop.