'Computer says no'published at 13:08 British Summer Time 26 May 2019
Andrew Benson
BBC Sport’s chief F1 writer in Monaco
The big story of qualifying was obviously Charles Leclerc, in a Ferrari, being knocked out in first qualifying, at his home grand prix, because of a miscalculation by the team. Basically, the engineers’ data for what is predicted to be the cut-off time - the lap time needed to go through - said he would be safe. Leclerc questioned it.
But in a classic example of F1-style ‘computer says no’ they believed the data, rather than common sense. In the bitterest of ironies, it was his team-mate Sebastian Vettel - who was sent out for another run - who dealt the final blow.
It was a terrible error, but the root cause of it was, as Vettel said, the lack of pace of both cars on their first runs - Leclerc was sixth quickest, but 0.3secs slower than Kevin Magnussen’s Haas. Which you would have thought would have been enough to ring alarm bells, but clearly wasn’t.
Vettel said: “We had to fit a second set of tyres because we were not quick enough with the first one. That is the real problem. The track ramped up more than expect and we got caught out but being half a second faster on the first run, you don’t get caught out.”