Bin Strike: Analysis on today's High Court judgementpublished at 17:05 British Summer Time 20 September 2017
Kathryn Stanczyszyn
Political Reporter, BBC WM
Make no mistake - today's High Court judgement to temporarily stop 106 binmen losing their jobs is a huge blow to Birmingham City Council.
Mr Justice Fraser couldn't have been clearer in his scathing remarks about the 'sorry saga' that led to this action that he believes both senior council officers, including interim chief executive Stella Manzie, and elected members, primarily former leader John Clancy, have acted badly.
He dismissed the council's argument that Mr Clancy had no authority to make a deal at ACAS with Unite, saying he was more than satisfied there's enough evidence of what was referred to in court as the 'Clancy Agreement' to be tested at a full trial. He also dismissed a submission by Birmingham City Council's legal team that a trial would not be in the public interest.
He did however urge all parties to come to some kind of agreement before the prospect of an expensive five-day trial in November.
With Unite empowered by a judgement that ,although temporary, (it does not yet hold the weight of a full legal decision) is clearly on their side, the onus now looks to be on the city council to concede something.