WATCH: Milner penalty gives Liverpool the leadpublished at 20:42 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Was it a penalty?
You decide.
Summary
Van Dijk header on debut sends Liverpool through
Milner penalty after Holgate adjudged to foul Lallana, Sigurdsson rolls in equaliser
Lingard stunner & Lukaku finish late on for Man Utd against Derby
Extended highlights from Old Trafford available on iPlayer
WATCH: Milner penalty gives Liverpool the leadpublished at 20:42 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Postpublished at 20:41 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
Derby's gameplan is looking good so far - yes they have soaked up a lot of pressure but every break they have had has carried a threat too.
Image source, ReutersCLOSE!published at 20:38 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
Still no goals at Old Trafford but Luke Shaw burrows his way into the area and doesn't quite get a shot away before Marcus Rashford heads straight at Scott Carson.
Image source, ReutersPostpublished at 20:37 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
No cards given after all that - Mason Holgate is a lucky man.
'Lost his head'published at 20:37 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Martin Keown
Former Arsenal defender on BBC OneIt looks like Mason Holgate has completely lost his head, as has Roberto Firmino.
Holgate is completely out of order pushing Firmino, but Firmino over-reacts. It was reckless and dangerous from Holgate. It was totally uncalled for and he is lucky to stay on here.
If I'm playing with Holgate, I want to calm him down.
Image source, Getty ImagesPostpublished at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
Kevin Kilbane
Former Republic of Ireland winger on BBC Radio 5 live sports extraMarcus Rashford definitely should score. He went for the glancing header. What a chance. He's three yards out.
HITS THE WOODWORKpublished at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
Manchester United have to score - but they don't. Henrikh Mkhitaryan whips in a fine cross which finds Marcus Rashford.
The striker is unmarked, about four yards out, and he heads it straight off the post. Such a let-off.
'Soft penalty - but you run the risk'published at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Phil McNulty
BBC Sport chief football writer at AnfieldReal blow to Everton as they were so comfortable. Soft penalty but once Mason Holgate laid his hands on Adam Lallana that was the risk he was running.
Everton, who in fairness have not simply been sitting back, now need to find the the threat to bring them a goal.
Postpublished at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
The referee is over talking to the fourth official now...
Postpublished at 20:35 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
It's bubbling over! Mason Holgate pushes Roberto Firmino into the crowd as he chases a ball off the pitch - that was needless and it brings a reaction from both sets of players.
That was silly from the Everton man...
Image source, ReutersA tweet from last monthpublished at 20:34 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on TwitterThe BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.Skip twitter postThe BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.Allow Twitter content?
This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.
End of twitter postget involved Get Involvedpublished at 20:34 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
#bbcfootball
Jeff Jones: Absolutely shocking penalty decision, Llalana just fell down, game's gone soft
Ashton Moore: Honestly? A pretty soft penalty. (And I'm a Liverpool fan.) And totally karma for the ultra-soft Calvert-Lewin penalty in the league. These things do even themselves out.
Craig Smith: Shocking decision, he barely touched him. Refs are giving pens way too easily. Soft has become very soft.
Andy: Adam Lallana gets a 6.5 for execution and 8.5 for artistic impression. Lightly touching someone's back doesn't constitute 'holding' and certainly doesn't make someone crash to the floor like that
Postpublished at 20:32 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Some tasty challenges are coming in now - Sam Allardyce is rabid on the touchline. He was clear that the penalty Everton got last month was correct, will he feel the same tonight?
'Harsh' penaltypublished at 20:32 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Robbie Savage
Ex-Leicester City & Wales midfielder on BBC Radio 5 liveThere's not much in that - Mason Holgate, has he pulled him back? I think that's harsh.
But Liverpool fans might say the Dejan Lovren push on Dominic Calvert-Lewin in the 1-1 draw was a bit harsh.
If that went to VAR, I wonder what the decision would be?
'Naive from Holgate'published at 20:31 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 1-0 Everton
Martin Keown
Former Arsenal defender on BBC OneI don't think he is holding on to him that much, but you can't put your arms around someone like that in the box. It was very naive from Mason Holgate.
It was a very calm penalty. Milner shows a steady head and just tickles it into the other side. It is a nice penalty. It was out of nothing, it is a gift for Liverpool.
WATCH: Carson tips Mata's free-kick round the postpublished at 20:30 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
It's been a good end to end encounter at Old Trafford so far.
This Juan Mata free-kick is the closest either side has come.
Postpublished at 20:30 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Manchester United 0-0 Derby
Kevin Kilbane
Former Republic of Ireland winger on BBC Radio 5 live sports extraLook at the body language of Henrikh Mkhitaryan. Everything he's doing at the moment is a mistake, his quality is letting him down at the final third.
GOAL - Liverpool 1-0 Evertonpublished at 20:29 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
James Milner (Pen 35 mins)
As cool as you like! James Milner steps up, Jordan Pickford goes early and Milner just dinks it down the middle. His first goal of the season.
PENALTY LIVERPOOLpublished at 20:29 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 0-0 Everton
Adam Lallana goes down = penalty!
Mason Holgate had his arms on the England man and he goes to ground.
Image source, Getty ImagesLallana quietpublished at 20:29 Greenwich Mean Time 5 January 2018
Liverpool 0-0 Everton
Martin Keown
Former Arsenal defender on BBC OneLiverpool pass the ball very quickly but we haven't seen much of Adam Lallana. When he clicks he will bring everything together.
Image source, Reuters