Roberto Colombi: Low Ki performance from the Toon so far.

Matt Parkman: He's quite a silKI player this lad... would be unlucKI not to be playing at the weekend.

Jon, Manchester: Schar just doesn't look strong enough.

First one to move the discussion on from Ki, Jon.

Newcastle almost level.

Kenedy's corner is flicked on by Spanish striker Joselu, but neither Yoshinori Muto nor Federico Fernandez can finish the job at the far post.

Joel Ucko: I have to admit that I am really impressed with Javi’s attitudes to this competition. He’s put a very strong team out despite 11 changes, which is only pushing the competition in the team even more.

The more competition, the more consistency there is from the 11 chosen.

Everton should be two in front.

Millers goalkeeper Lewis Price spills Sandro Ramirez's vicious long-range strike and goalscorer Gylfi Sigurdsson somehow scoops the follow up over the bar.

Newcastle fell behind early on and have not looked like getting back into the contest.

Forest goalkeeper Luke Steele has had a comfortable evening in the between the sticks so far.

Stephen Warnock
Ex-Liverpool defender on BBC Radio 5 Live

Forest are willing to run in behind and test defenders. They've been enterprising, bright and lively so far tonight.

At one end we’re seeing a lot of promise. At the other end we’re definitely not.

Reading controlling the bulk of possession so far against Watford but chances have been few and far between in the opening 10 minutes.

Spanish defender Marc Navarro, on his Watford debut, struck a long-range free-kick at the Reading goal but Royals goalkeeper Sam Walker saves easily.

Image source, Reuters

Shane Ferguson is the first to go close for the home team, latching onto Tom Elliott's knockdown and shooting from distance. His half volley loops up off Ryan Edwards over Matt Macey and drops on top of the net.

Chris, Birmingham: Darlow, is it Ki you're looking for?

Thomas: Do you think coming to Newcastle was a bad Korea move for Ki?

What have we started?

Leandro Bacuna in action for Reading today, did you see his brother Juninho's own goal for Huddersfield last night?

Absolutely comical it was.

Image source, Getty Images

Everton have finally managed to work Rotherham goalkeeper Lewis Price, but it is a comfortable save from Gylfi Sigurdsson's shot.

Andy Reid
Ex-Nottingham Forest and Tottenham midfielder on 5 live

Forest have been excellent. They've wanted to play out from the back as well as play off Daryl Murphy's knockdowns. The game plan has been very good so far and it's exactly what I expected from them.

They've not allowed Newcastle to get going.

Joe Lolley has got a magical left foot.

The former Huddersfield winger weaves inside and out of a number of Newcastle challenges, reaching the edge of the box, but his run is put to an end by Sean Longstaff's well-timed tackle.

Image source, Getty Images

Still just the one goal in our four Carabao Cup games.

Image source, Getty Images

Tom Orr: Ki has the ability to unlock this defence...

A slight improvement...

Plymouth can cause the shock of the night in this game, they have come close to breaking the deadlock.

Jamie Ness exchanges passes with Antoni Sarcevic, but the effort is smothered by Millwall goalkeeper Ben Amos.

Stephen Warnock
Ex-Liverpool defender on BBC Radio 5 Live

Newcastle are going long a lot at the moment looking for Joselu. The ball has to be so precise for that to work though. It's the same as it was at Cardiff.

Forest look very confident - obviously going a goal up has only added to that. They're picking up the ball and drive at Newcastle to make things happen.

The Newcastle players look like they can't wait to get rid of it and need to improve massively.

Sunday league stuff at Goodison Park at the moment.

A hoof forward, headed away, mis-control, mis-placed pass, headed away again, players falling over.

That'll be a clip on social media soon, keep a lookout.

Image source, Getty Images

David Huggan: Ki could be the key player for Newcastle tonight (Dad joke)

We must be able to do better...