Chris Waddle
BBC Radio 5 live at Old Trafford

"PSV have deserved the draw - Man Utd started at a great tempo but had very little quality in the final third. In the last 15 minutes PSV looked the better side."

And a really bad result for Manchester United. That leaves their qualification right in the balance.

Image source, Getty Images

Ultimately another frustrating night for Manchester City...

Image source, Getty Images

My oh my! Incredible scenes at Shakhtar Donetsk as they score a third against Real Madrid! Alex Teixeira's neat finish means they trail 4-3 with two minutes left. Could they...?

Rafael Benitez looks rattled as he screams instructions from the edge of his technical area.

Image source, AP

88 minutes. Nothing going on. If you'd have told me during my youth that I'd ever watch a Manchester United side so devoid of urgency and attacking threat, I'd have told you I'd believe it when Woolworths and Our Price shut down...

Image source, Getty Images

A five-star performance for PSG at Malmo as Lucas Moura grabs a fifth with a inch-perfect free-kick.

Real Madrid, who remember had not conceded at all in the Champions League before tonight, have just conceded a second at Shakhtar Donetsk, Dentinho heading in. Real lead 4-2, but a nervy few minutes ahead.

Roars from the home fans. They fancy something here...

Both of these sides are going through, but it looks like Juve who will win the group if it stays like this...

Five minutes left. Juan Mata on for Matteo Darmian.

Load the trebuchet and sling it towards Marouane Fellaini...

Image source, Getty Images

To clarify, United will need to win in Wolfsburg in the final game to be sure of qualification if it stays like this. Not the sort of shot you want to leave yourself. A tricky black across the cushion. 

It's been very flat again from Manchester United. Where's the fizz gone?

Real Madrid concede for the first time in this season's Champions League as Alex Teixeira strokes home a penalty for Shakhtar Donetsk to make it 4-1.

Meanwhile, Borussia Monchengladbach are cruising to victory against Sevilla, with second-half strikes from Fabian Johnson and Raffael make it 3-0.

Elsewhere, Antoinne Griezmann has made it 2-0 for Atletico Madrid against Galatasaray.

Problems here for City now as Joe Hart has to come off. Looked like he opened up his groin in making that fine save from Alvaro Morata a moment or so again. Willy Caballero is on, Hart goes straight down the tunnel. 

Chris Waddle
BBC Radio 5 live at Old Trafford

"This could be a very long 15 minutes for Manchester United given the way they are playing at the moment. They have put so much work into this game - they are really feeling the pace now."

Should be 1-1 - poor miss from Raheem Sterling! A cross comes in from the right, Sterling slides in but gets his angles all wrong, shanking it wide. Manuel Pellegrini has his head in his hands.

Image source, Reuters

Joe Hart likes to showcase himself on Champions League nights and he makes another big stop to deny Alvaro Morata from adding a second. Morata was majestic to pin and roll his man on halfway, skip away from another and open up the goal. A tap-in? No, Hart slams the door!

Image source, Getty Images

BBC Radio 5 Live

Where have the entertaining Man Utd of the past gone?

Why are Man City so light up front at the moment?

That will be one of the subjects we want to hear about on the Radio 5 live football social. Text 85058 or call 0500 909693. Lines are open now.

City still labouring away, but at the risk of re-covering old ground, take Aguero, Silva and Kompany out of this team and the wheels rather come off.

Any team would miss those players of course...

Image source, EPA

Goals, goals, goals at Shakhtar Donetsk and they are all being scored by Real Madrid, who now lead 4-0. Cristiano Ronaldo scores the fourth after great work from Gareth Bale. The Wales international pounced on a loose ball to race away down the left before crossing low for Ronaldo to swipe home at the second attempt.

Two goals from Ronaldo in this game and two assists by Bale.

Meanwhile, PSG are also racking up the goals now as Angel Di Maria gets his second of the game, heading home from a cross to make it 4-0 at Malmo.