Penalty - England 13-12 Scotlandpublished at 40+2 mins
Owen Farrell
As safe as houses. England lead at the break.
Summary
Scotland retain Calcutta Cup with dramatic 29-23 bonus-point victory
First time Scotland have secured back-to-back wins at Twickenham
Duhan van der Merwe powered over for match-winning try in 76th minute
Ellis Genge and Ben White exchanged tries in end-to-end second half
Max Malins touched down twice as England led 13-12 at half-time
Van der Merwe scored stunning 60m try after Huw Jones opener
Get involved using #bbcrugby on Twitter
Penalty - England 13-12 Scotlandpublished at 40+2 mins
Postpublished at 40+1 mins
England 10-12 Scotland
Penalty to England with the clock in the red.
Owen Farrell has missed both of his attempts at the posts so far but he won't miss this one. It will be enough for England to take the lead before the interval.
'Farrell has been instrumental'published at 17:28 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 10-12 Scotland
Matt Dawson
Former England scrum-half on BBC Radio 5 LiveThe same pattern from England you have to be patience if you are going to play phase play Just look for the edge and on that occasion there was only a sniff of an overlap. Farrell has been instrumental.
'He doesn't want to rue opportunities'published at 17:27 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 10-12 Scotland
Matt Dawson
Former England scrum-half on BBC Radio 5 LiveYou always wonder at this level, two points can be so crucial. With a man of Owen Farrell's kicking percentage he does not want to be ruing those opportunities.
Try - England 10-12 Scotlandpublished at 37 mins
Max Malins
Max Malins at the double!
England get their hands on the ball and they are able to manouevre the blue shirts and create the overlap.
It's slick hands in midfield before Lewis Ludlam feeds Malins for a simple run-in.
He's been waiting a while for an international try and now he has two in the first-half.
Owen Farrell, uncharacteristically, misses the conversion.
Image source, Getty Images'England forcing things'published at 17:23 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
John Barclay
Former Scotland captain on BBC Radio 5 LiveI think it is interesting where the game is going the stadium is simmering down. Like Dombrandt, England are trying to force things here. You need your big carriers and a low error count.
Postpublished at 35 mins
England 5-12 Scotland
Scotland have silenced Twickenham again after that Max Malins try.
The visitors are controlling the territory at the minute and limiting England's time on the ball.
'Who is going to blink first'published at 17:20 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
Katy Daley-Mclean
England's 2014 World Cup-winning captain on BBC Radio 5 LiveAs soon as anybody is kicking Marcus Smith is going straight back in field, getting ready to kick again. It's about a massive territory battle, who is going to blink first almost.
'He must be fuming!'published at 17:18 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
Matt Dawson
Former England scrum-half on BBC Radio 5 LiveCan you imagine what is going through Kevin Sinfield's [England's defence coach] mind right now? He must be fuming!
'One of the best!'published at 17:18 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
John Barclay
Former Scotland captain on BBC Radio 5 LiveThat will go down as one of the best all-time individual tries.
'That's why you get him on the ball'published at 17:18 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
Peter Wright
Former Scotland prop on BBC Radio ScotlandWhen he gets checked, he gets into his running again very quickly.
That's why you get him on the ball. What a try.
Postpublished at 31 mins
England 5-12 Scotland
It's not been short of entertainment.
A penny for this man's thoughts after half an hour in the new job..?
Image source, Getty Images'Dombrandt has no chance at the end'published at 17:17 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-12 Scotland
John Barclay
Former Scotland captain on BBC Radio 5 LiveThat is the one man on the pitch you do not want to kick the ball loosely too... Then what a finish! Beat Steward, Malins, Dombrandt has no chance at the end.
Try - England 5-12 Scotlandpublished at 28 mins
Duhan van der Merwe
You may not see a better try in this tournament!
Duhan van der Merwe is a man mountain but he has bags of guile and shows deft footwork to get over.
He steps past one white shirt, bursts clear and then shrugs off another in a stunning individual score.
Finn Russell misses the conversion.
Media caption, 'One for the history books' - van der Merwe scores brilliant try
Postpublished at 27 mins
England 5-7 Scotland
Bang.
Owen Farrell has been after Finn Russell from the opening minute.
Russell created the first try with his pass for Huw Jones but Farrell gets his man that time with a thumping tackle.
'The crowd are loving it'published at 17:13 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-7 Scotland
Katy Daley-Mclean
England's 2014 World Cup-winning captain on BBC Radio 5 LiveWhat a start, the crowd is loving this game. The energy from England when they haven't got the ball, I can hear Jamie George and I am five rows back!
'Not an easy finish'published at 17:11 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-7 Scotland
Matt Dawson
Former England scrum-half on BBC Radio 5 LiveThat was not an easy finish from Max Malins. He needed to make a decision while the ball was floating in the air. Did he want to dive for it? Did he want to wait for it to hit the ground?
Ball on the deck, grounded.
I was seeing a replay and I'm hesitating but the TMO has had a look at it and it's fine. It was a risky move.
'Poor defence from Scotland'published at 17:11 Greenwich Mean Time 4 February 2023
England 5-7 Scotland
Peter Wright
Former Scotland prop on BBC Radio ScotlandThat's a good try.
Marcus Smith comes up really flat and sees Malins.
It's poor defence from Duhan van der Merwe.
Try - England 5-7 Scotlandpublished at 22 mins
Max Malins
A first international try for Max Malins.
England are banging on the door and, after 14 phases, Marcus Smith gets his hands on the ball.
He opts to kick wide, where Malins is on hand to dive forward and claim the ball over the touchline.
Owen Farrell misses the conversion.
Postpublished at 19 mins
England 0-7 Scotland
Out of nothing, England are on the front foot.
Max Malins swings the right boot at the ball on its way back down to earth and it fortuitously rolls behind the Scottish defensive line.
Big chance for the hosts.