1. 'I knew my yellow card had been cancelled' - Onanapublished at 11:30 British Summer Time 22 April

    Coventry City 3-3 Man Utd (United won 4-2 on penalties)

    Manchester United's Andre Onana gets a yellow card during the penalty shootout against CoventryImage source, Getty Images

    Manchester United goalkeeper Andre Onana said he was eager to provoke Coventry City’s players during the penalty shootout to give his side a crucial advantage in their FA Cup semi-final after knowing his yellow card during the match had been "cancelled", reports the Mail, external.

    "Before the penalties I knew that my first yellow card had been cancelled so I was aware of the rules," he said.

    "I had to make some provocation to some players and to use my tricks to win the game, so I’m happy for that."

    Ben Sheaf missed Coventry's decisive spot-kick after Onana had already saved from Callum O'Hare, with Rasmus Hojlund then stepping up to fire United into the final.

    Onana's second booking of the game, without being sent off, followed the same scenario in Aston Villa's Europa Conference League victory over Lille on penalties on Thursday, when Villa keeper Emiliano Martinez was also shown two yellow cards - in normal time and during the shootout.

    So, as Phil explained in the previous post, it turns out yellow cards are not carried over into a shootout...who knew?

    Well, potentially not Martinez, who cut a relieved figure in Lille after he was allowed to continue in goal for the remainder of the shootout, but Onana clearly made a calculated decision at Wembley on Sunday.

    Emi Martinez is shown a yellow card during Aston Villa's victory over LilleImage source, Getty Images
  2. Phil McNulty Q&A - Onana card confusionpublished at 11:26 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Andre Onana booked during FA Cup semi-final penalty shootoutImage source, Getty Images

    Martin from Oxsted: Hi Phil. Andre Onana received his second yellow card of the game during the penalty shootout yesterday in the FA Cup semi-final. Why didn't he get sent off, please?

    Hi, Martin. This is because bookings from regulation time do not carry over into the shoot-out. He will also play in the final because you can only be suspended for a red card not accumulated yellow cards.

  3. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:17 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, via WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (standard network charges apply)

    I wouldn't put it past Man Utd to try to poach Mark Robins after they sack Erik ten Hag. Robins is a special managerial talent and he's got to be on a few PL radars, but I really hope he stays at Cov and gets them promoted, he and the city deserve it.

    Scott

    Mark Robins applauds Coventry fans at WembleyImage source, Getty Images
  4. Phil McNulty Q&A - Alonso to Man Utd?published at 11:10 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Yusuf, Man Utd fan, London: Should Manchester United stick with Erik ten Hag for next season, to save on early contract release costs and so other teams get their new bosses lined up, and wait for Xabi Alonso to become available and take over?

    The debate is out there again this morning, Yusuf, isn’t it? You must assume decisions of this magnitude have already been taken but that performance in the FA Cup semi-final surely damaged Ten Hag’s case to keep his job.

    The only thing that might save Ten Hag is if United’s new leadership feels he has been held back by the poor structure that has hampered his predecessors at Old Trafford and deserves a chance under the new set-up but his future must surely be in doubt, even more so after yesterday.

    I actually think Xabi Alonso’s strong links with Liverpool would stop him taking the Manchester United job – and anyway Real Madrid might have him in their sights by then.

  5. Phil McNulty Q&A - 'damaging performance' for Ten Hagpublished at 11:03 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Manchester United manager Erik ten HagImage source, Getty Images

    Alex, Reading: Is this it now for Manchester United manager Erik ten Hag? It feels like there's no way back, even if they win the FA Cup?

    Winning the FA Cup may yet alter the argument, Alex, but even that may not be enough. It is very rare that an FA Cup semi-final win increases pressure on a manager but I’m afraid the shambolic nature of Manchester United’s last 20 minutes has done exactly that for Erik ten Hag.

    It was a performance that further damaged the standing of Ten Hag and United’s players. If ever an FA Cup semi-final win can be regarded as an embarrassment, Manchester United’s win over Coventry City might just fall into that category.

  6. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:00 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, via WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (standard network charges apply)

    Utd/Coventry feels a bit like Chesterfield in 1997; the irony being that if Chesterfield had the technology they would have made the the cup final, yesterday without the technology Coventry would be in it…

    Andy

  7. Phil McNulty Q&A - huge week for Evertonpublished at 10:51 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Everton players celebrate Idrissa Gueye's goal against Nottingham ForestImage source, Getty Images

    Steve, Worcester: Hi Phil, with all the talk about Forest this morning, can we also mention what a huge win for Everton that is. With an away game v Luton coming up, that was crucial yesterday to their survival, thanks.

    Hi Steve, all the penalty debate and Nottingham Forest’s social media statement certainly overshadowed Everton’s win but it was absolutely vital for the reasons you state. And it was certainly needed after the embarrassment of the 6-0 loss at Chelsea.

    This is a huge week for Everton with two more home games against Liverpool and Brentford before that potentially defining game at Kenilworth Road.

    It was a battle settled by two moments of quality but, in many ways, so typical of the wins Sean Dyche has had at Goodison Park since he has been at Everton.

  8. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 10:45 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Nottingham Forest overspent on mediocrity and sacked Steve Cooper, the man who took the club into the EPL and kept it there. Therein lies the reasons the club is flirting with relegation. If the club is looking for something to be angry at, it needs to look in the mirror.

    Martin

  9. 'Wrong to question referee's integrity'published at 10:43 British Summer Time 22 April

    Everton 2-0 Nott'm Forest

    More from former Premier League referee Peter Walton, speaking to BBC 5 Live Breakfast: "All factors must be looked into and Mark [Clattenburg] being there as an advisor, I'm sure they've listened to some of the advice he's given them.

    "But whoever has given that advice, I think is clearly wrong in terms of looking at that core integrity value.

    "Referees make wrong decisions, I made wrong decisions but I didn't do it on purpose and one thing we should not have questioned is our impartiality towards teams. When I refereed Manchester United v Spurs, I was refereeing reds versus whites, the team factor didn't come into it.

    "To name an individual and accuse that individual of cheating is poor in its entirety.

    "Who you support, where you live, who you've refereed before, the league factors all of these things in. So I'm sure the PGMOL would have been aware beforehand if he is a Luton Town fan and factored it in."

  10. ICYMI: 'A hat-trick of howlers' - Clattenburg has his saypublished at 10:40 British Summer Time 22 April

    Everton 2-0 Nottm Forest

    Mark Clattenburg watching in the stands at Goodison ParkImage source, Getty Images

    In case you missed it, Mark Clattenburg, the retired referee who is Nottingham Forest's referee analyst, defended the club's response in a column published on the Daily Mail's website on Sunday.

    He wrote: "One of these errors would have been bad enough. Three was a joke, and that is why Nottingham Forest were left feeling victimised after another defeat in which zero big decisions went their way.

    "In a season where they have had to endure some egregious refereeing, this trip to Everton was as grim a game as they have encountered since returning to the Premier League.

    "These situations were precisely why video technology was brought into the Premier League and yet, Attwell did not send Taylor to his monitor. Not once. It was a hat-trick of howlers from the refereeing team and, unfortunately for Forest, a continuation of an unjust trend that has hampered their survival fight.

    "You will have seen the statement released by the club - how the PGMOL were contacted to warn that it was not appropriate for a Luton fan such as Attwell to play such a pivotal role in a massive match that would impact the relegation race."

  11. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 10:31 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Unfortunately, referee and VAR controversies have cost Forest far more than the four-point PSR deduction this season. As a fan of the club for over 40 years, I have never known officiating to be as bad as it is now and yesterday's statement is the frustrating culmination of too many bad decisions this season.

    Craig, Nottingham

  12. 'If a ref is useless, he's useless - but he's not a cheat'published at 10:27 British Summer Time 22 April

    Everton 2-0 Nott'm Forest

    Peter Whalton during his days as a Premier League refereeImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Peter Walton, pictured in 2010, during his days as a Premier League referee

    Former Premier League referee Peter Walton, speaking to BBC 5 Live Breakfast: "It is unprecedented and it shouldn't be allowed at all.

    "If it came from a fan then maybe you could understand it but coming from an official club website is poor. The issue here is that if the referee is useless, he's useless - but he's not a cheat. It is an integrity issue.

    "That is why our league and our referees are valued around the world because we just do not have that issue. There may well be issues around the world where leagues can influence the assignment of match officials but in Britain, that doesn't happen.

    "We should nip this in the bud straightaway."

  13. 'Officiating more professional than it's ever been'published at 10:23 British Summer Time 22 April

    Everton 2-0 Nott'm Forest

    John Murray
    Commentator on BBC Radio 5 Live

    For that to be an official statement by a Premier League club is remarkable really.

    The next step, seeing how the Football Association responds, will be interesting because, in my experience dealing with those who officiate at the top of the game, the absolute key for them, first and foremost, ahead of everything else, is impartiality and being fair.

    Things like which team you support are a factor, people know that, but officiating is now more professional than it's ever been before.

    They are trying to reach the standards - people will laugh at that when they see some of the decisions that are made - but that is what they are trying to do and the key to that is impartiality.

    That's why what Nottingham Forest said is such a serious allegation.

  14. What did Forest post on X?published at 10:20 British Summer Time 22 April

    Everton 2-0 Nottm Forest

    Here is a reminder of what was posted on Nottingham Forest's official X account after Sunday's 2-0 defeat at Everton, when Toffees defender Ashley Young was involved in three incidents that the visitors believed warranted a penalty:

    "Three extremely poor decisions - three penalties not given - which we simply cannot accept. We warned the PGMOL that the VAR is a Luton fan before the game but they didn’t change him. Our patience has been tested multiple times. NFFC will now consider its options."

  15. Phil McNulty Q&A - Forest VAR postpublished at 10:12 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, via WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (standard network charges apply)

    Matt, Birmingham: Surely an accusation of bias, like that made by Nottingham Forest's X account, requires some evidence beyond "they support Luton"? Or are they just trying to deflect from their performance?

    Have to be very careful answering this one, Matt, but there is a clear inference from Forest that being a “Luton fan” influenced decisions taken at Everton yesterday. This suggests the integrity of the officials is compromised and that simply cannot be allowed to stand.

    In all our time as football fans we have accused officials of being incompetent against our own team (well, I assume we have) in moments of frustration, but there can never be any suggestion of something deeper.

    I do not believe for one second that is the case when it comes to officialdom in this country.

    I was at Goodison and actually feel if Nuno Espirito Santo had simply come out and said Nottingham Forest had been on the end of some really rough decisions plenty would have sympathised. I certainly would. Now a lot of that sympathy has been diluted by the post-match statement.

    On Forest’s performance - they were actually very poor in what was a pretty poor game.

    Everton's Ashley Young attempts to tackle Callum Hudson-Odoi in the penalty area before Nottingham Forest's claims for a handball are dismissed by officialsImage source, Getty Images
  16. Phil McNulty Q&Apublished at 10:05 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    Just another talking point to throw into the mix...as if we needed another!

    Right, you have been getting in touch in your droves this morning with questions for Phil McNulty, BBC Sport's chief football writer.

    I am glad to say he is ready to start providing you with some answers.

    Remember, keep those questions coming using the contact details above.

    Ta...

  17. 'You have to put in the technology'published at 09:59 British Summer Time 22 April

    Real Madrid 3-2 Barcelona

    Xavi appeals to match officialsImage source, Getty Images

    Yes, you read that right.

    One of the big talking points after Real Madrid's last-gasp victory at home to rivals Barcelona on Sunday was the lack of goal-line technology.

    Jude Bellingham took the plaudits with an injury-time winner for Real, but Barca boss Xavi was adamant that his side was denied a goal earlier in the match that he believes would have changed the course of the game.

    The visitors thought they had gone 2-1 up in the first half when Lamine Yamal flicked a corner towards goal and Real goalkeeper Andriy Lunin, who was behind the line, clawed it away.

    Fermin Lopez did manage to score a second for Barca after the break before efforts from Lucas Vazquez and Bellingham gave La Liga leaders Real the three points.

    "It's a disgrace," said Xavi, who was furious after VAR officials could not prove that Yamal's effort had crossed the line, complaining that the goal-line technology used in other top flights, including the Premier League, is not available in La Liga.

    "If we want to be the best league in the world we have to advance in this sense, you have to put in the technology."

    Barcelona goalkeeper Marc-Andre ter Stegen agreed with his coach.

    "It's shameful for football, I don't have the words," said the Germany international.

    "There's so much money in this world and there's no money for what's most important."

    Read the full match report here.

  18. 'Heartbreak'published at 09:55 British Summer Time 22 April

    Monday's back pages

    The Daily Mail

    We finish our round-up of today's back pages with the Mail, which has a picture of Coventry manager Mark Robins, head in hands, next to those VAR lines.

    That, and Nottingham Forest's reaction to their own VAR issues, has provided the biggest talking point of the morning so far.

    But if you think English football has tech problems, a news line that came out of the El Classico yesterday is hard to fathom...there is no goal-line technology in La Liga!

    More on that coming up.

    Mail back pageImage source, Daily Mail
  19. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 09:49 British Summer Time 22 April

    #bbcfootball, WhatsApp on 03301231826 or text 81111 (UK only, standard message rates apply)

    The players at Manchester United are good enough to beat Coventry. Even with all the injuries, they are good enough to keep the ball and get a result. Something is off with what Erik ten Hag is telling them to do.

    Ben, Manchester

    I think it’s being blown a bit out of proportion, a dodgy handball call and a ridiculous deflection (which definitely should’ve been saved anyway) let Coventry back into the game. The real problem is when Erik takes off Garnacho we have no credible forward threat anymore and so the opposition can afford to throw more players forward without worrying about the likes of Anthony and Rashford who have been too easy to defend this season.

    A Man Utd fan considering switching to cricket

    Lots of talk of VAR and Coventry's offside goal, but none of the 'handball' that took the game to extra-time in the first place. Could we have a bit of balance, please?

    Ryan Howard

  20. 'Toe no'published at 09:38 British Summer Time 22 April

    Monday's back pages

    The Daily Star

    The Star reports that Coventry's FA Cup dreams were "Torpedoed" by VAR after Victor Torp's extra-time goal for the Sky Blues was ruled out for offside by "millimetres".

    Star back pageImage source, Daily Star